Whether individuals can rely on EU treaty rules before national courts
In Van Gend en Loos, the Court was asked whether Article 12 of the EEC Treaty, which bans higher customs duties between Member States, can be relied on by individuals in national courts. The Court answered yes, but left the duty question to the national court.
The case
The applicant, a transport and forwarding company based in Utrecht, imported urea-formaldehyde from the Federal Republic of Germany into the Netherlands in 1960 [1][2]. The Netherlands Inland Revenue Administration applied an import duty of 8% to the goods [1]. The company argued that the new Benelux customs tariff, in force from 1 March 1960, moved the product into a more heavily taxed heading and raised the duty from 3% to a higher rate, which it said breached Article 12 of the EEC Treaty [2]. The Tariefcommissie, a Dutch administrative tribunal, asked the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling on two questions in August 1962 [2]. The first asked whether Article 12 has direct application, meaning that individuals can rely on it before national courts. The second asked whether the duty was an unlawful increase or a reasonable alteration [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether Article 12 of the EEC Treaty has direct effect, so that individuals can rely on it before national courts [1]. If it does, the Court had to decide whether the change in duty on the product was an unlawful increase under Article 12 [1].
The outcome
The Court ruled that Article 12 produces direct effect and creates individual rights that national courts must protect [1]. On the second question, it ruled that an increase can arise from a re-arrangement of the tariff or from a higher rate, and that the national court must check the duty applied on the date the Treaty entered into force [1]. The Court did not decide the dispute itself, and the sources do not state who won the case [1].
The Court’s reasoning
The Court first held that it had jurisdiction. It said that the Court needs only a question that clearly concerns the interpretation of the Treaty, and that the reasons for a national court's choice of questions are not reviewed by the Court [1]. On the first question, the Court looked at the spirit, general scheme and wording of the Treaty [1]. It said the EEC Treaty is more than an agreement creating only mutual obligations between states. It creates a new legal order of international law whose subjects include nationals of the Member States [1]. Community law therefore imposes obligations on individuals and also confers rights on them, which arise where the Treaty imposes clearly defined obligations on individuals, Member States and Community institutions [1]. Article 12 contains a clear and unconditional negative obligation that needs no further national measure, so it is suited to direct effect [1]. The Court also rejected the argument based on Articles 169 and 170. Those articles allow the Commission and Member States to bring a defaulting state before the Court, but they do not stop individuals pleading the same obligations before national courts [1]. Limiting protection to those procedures would remove direct legal protection of individuals' rights [1]. On the second question, the Court held that it concerned the interpretation of Article 12, namely the meaning of duties applied before the Treaty entered into force [1]. An increase can arise from a re-arrangement of the tariff or from a higher rate [1]. The national court must decide whether the product was charged a higher duty than on 1 January 1958 [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment's main importance is the principle of direct effect: an individual may invoke a clear, unconditional Treaty obligation before a national court, which must protect the rights it creates [1]. The Court based this on the nature of the Treaty, the wording of Article 12 and the view that the Treaty confers rights on individuals as well as imposing obligations [1]. On this reading, the judgment does not decide the Dutch dispute itself. The Court did not say whether the 8% duty was an unlawful increase. It left that to the national court, which must check which duties applied on the date the Treaty entered into force [1]. It also does not settle how far the principle reaches for other Treaty provisions. The reasoning rests on Article 12 and its wording, and the sources do not show how it would apply to provisions worded differently [1]. The Advocate General argued that many Treaty provisions create only obligations for Member States, which suggests that direct effect depends on each provision [2]. This summary is not advice, and it cannot predict how other cases will be decided.
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General, Karl Roemer, proposed answering the first question in the negative. He argued that Article 12 should be treated like other customs union rules and that its wording did not show direct effect [2]. The Court reached the opposite conclusion and held that Article 12 produces direct effects and creates individual rights that national courts must protect [1]. The Court treated the second question as one of interpretation within its jurisdiction, while the Advocate General had examined it only as a subsidiary question [1][2]. Later judgments cite the case. A 1963 ruling in Case 28/62 quotes the operative part of this judgment [3]. Case C-100/89 cites it on direct effect [4], and Case C-93/02 cites it on consistency within the Community legal order [5].
From the sources
Article 12 of the treaty establishing the european economic community produces direct effects and creates individual rights which national courts must protect [1]
The wording of article 12 contains a clear and unconditional prohibition which is not a positive but a negative obligation [1]
The fact that these articles of the treaty enable the commission and the member states to bring before the court a state which has not fulfilled its obligations does not mean that individuals cannot plead these obligations [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-26/62: Judgment of the Court of 5 February 1963. — NV Algemene Transport- en Expeditie Onderneming van Gend & Loos v Netherlands Inland Revenue Administration. the judgment · 5 February 1963
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-26/62: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Roemer delivered on 12 December 1962. — NV Algemene Transport- en Expeditie Onderneming van Gend & Loos v Netherlands In the Advocate General's opinion · 12 December 1962
- Judgment in Case C-28/62: Judgment of the Court of 27 March 1963. — Da Costa en Schaake NV, Jacob Meijer NV, Hoechst-Holland NV v Netherlands Inland Revenue Administration. a later judgment that cites this case · 27 March 1963
- Judgment in Case C-100/89: Judgment of the Court of 12 December 1990. — Peter Kaefer and Andréa Procacci v French State. a later judgment that cites this case · 12 December 1990
- Judgment in Case C-93/02: Judgment of the Court (Full Court) of 30 September 2003. — Biret International SA v Council of the European Union. a later judgment that cites this case · 30 September 2003