Viking: union action against a ferry company's reflagging plans
The Viking case asked whether union action against a ferry firm's plan to reflag a ship falls outside EU freedom of establishment rules. The Court said it is not excluded in principle, and may be justified by worker protection if proportionate.
The case
Viking Line, a Finnish ferry operator, ran the Rosella under the Finnish flag on the Tallinn-Helsinki route [1]. Estonian crew wages were generally lower than Finnish crew wages, and the vessel ran at a loss because of competition from Estonian ships on the same route [1]. In October 2003 Viking planned to reflag the ship to Estonia or Norway so that it could sign a new collective agreement with a local union [1]. The Finnish Seamen's Union (FSU) opposed the plan. The International Transport Workers' Federation (ITF), which the FSU belongs to, sent a circular asking its affiliated unions not to negotiate with Viking [1]. The FSU then gave notice of a strike. Viking conceded extra crew and agreed not to reflag before 28 February 2005 [1]. Viking later brought an action in England, where the court granted the orders it sought. The ITF and FSU appealed, and the Court of Appeal referred questions to the Court of Justice [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether trade union collective action aimed at keeping Finnish pay terms for a ship's crew falls outside the EU right of establishment in Article 43 EC [1]. It also had to decide whether a company can rely on that article against a trade union, and whether such action is a restriction that can be justified [1].
The outcome
The Court held that such collective action is not, in principle, excluded from Article 43 EC [1]. It held that Article 43 EC can be relied on by a private undertaking against a trade union [1]. It also held that the action restricts freedom of establishment and may be justified by the protection of workers, if it is suitable and does not go beyond what is necessary, leaving that assessment to the national court [1].
The Court’s reasoning
The Court relied first on its case law that Article 43 EC applies not only to public authorities but also to rules that regulate work collectively, such as collective agreements [1]. Working conditions are sometimes set by law and sometimes by agreements between private parties, so limiting the rule to public authorities would create unequal application [1]. Trade unions organise collective action under their legal autonomy, and such action is inextricably linked to the collective agreement sought, so it falls in principle within Article 43 EC [1]. The Court also held that the right to strike is a fundamental right forming part of the general principles of EU law [1]. However, this does not make Article 43 inapplicable [1]. The Court rejected the argument that the reasoning in Albany could be applied, because it cannot be considered inherent in trade union rights that the freedoms will be prejudiced [1]. On horizontal effect, the Court stated that abolishing State barriers would be compromised if they could be neutralised by obstacles from the autonomy of organisations not governed by public law [1]. On restriction, the Court found that the action makes the exercise of establishment less attractive or even pointless, and that the ITF policy is at least liable to restrict it [1]. On justification, the protection of workers is an overriding reason of public interest, but the national court must check whether jobs were under serious threat and whether less restrictive means existed [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment's main point is that collective action by trade unions against a company is not outside EU freedom of establishment rules just because it serves social policy or the right to strike [1]. The right to strike is recognised as a fundamental right, but it must be reconciled with the freedoms and with proportionality [1]. The judgment also establishes that Article 43 EC can be relied on by a private company against a trade union, which extends these freedoms into relations between private parties [1]. On this reading, this matters for employers that plan to move a business or register a vessel abroad, and for unions that act to protect pay and jobs [1]. The judgment does not decide the case itself. It leaves to the national court whether the jobs were under serious threat and whether the action went beyond what was necessary [1]. It does not answer the question under Regulation No 4055/86, which was treated as hypothetical because the vessel had not yet been reflagged [1]. It does not say that any particular strike is lawful or unlawful. The answer depends on the facts and the national court's assessment [1]. This is an assessment, not legal advice.
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General, Poiares Maduro, proposed that collective action pursuing social policy is not, for that reason alone, exempt from Article 43 EC and Regulation No 4055/86 [2]. The Court followed this on Article 43 EC, but it treated the Regulation question as hypothetical and did not answer it [1]. The Advocate General also proposed horizontal effect, and the Court held that Article 43 EC is capable of conferring rights on a private undertaking against a trade union [2][1]. Later judgments cite this case for the protection of workers as an overriding reason in the public interest [3]. Others cite it for the duty to balance interests between private parties [4], for the test that a restriction must be suitable and not go beyond what is necessary [6], and for the definition of establishment through registration of a vessel [5].
From the sources
the right to take collective action, including the right to strike, must therefore be recognised as a fundamental right which forms an integral part of the general principles of Community law [1]
the fundamental nature of the right to take collective action is not such as to render Article 43 EC inapplicable to the collective action at issue in the main proceedings. [1]
the protection of workers is one of the overriding reasons of public interest recognised by the Court [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-438/05: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 11 December 2007. — International Transport Workers’ Federation and Finnish Seamen’s Union v Viking Line ABP and OÜ Viking Line Eest the judgment · 11 December 2007
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-438/05: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Poiares Maduro delivered on 23 May 2007. — International Transport Workers’ Federation and Finnish Seamen’s Union v Vik the Advocate General's opinion · 23 May 2007
- Judgment in Case C-201/15: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 21 December 2016. — Anonymi Geniki Etairia Tsimenton Iraklis (AGET Iraklis) v Ypourgos Ergasias, Koinonikis Asfalisis kai Koinonikis a later judgment that cites this case · 21 December 2016
- Judgment in Case C-414/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 17 April 2018. — Vera Egenberger v Evangelisches Werk für Diakonie und Entwicklung e.V. a later judgment that cites this case · 17 April 2018
- Judgment in Case C-71/20: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 8 July 2021. — Criminal proceedings against VAS Shipping ApS. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 July 2021
- Judgment in Case C-407/19: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 11 February 2021. — Katoen Natie Bulk Terminals NV and General Services Antwerp NV v Belgische Staat and Middlegate Europe NV v Min a later judgment that cites this case · 11 February 2021