Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

National courts cannot declare EU acts invalid; only the Court of Justice can

Court of JusticeTax, VAT and customsJudgment in Case C-314/8522 October 1987

In Foto-Frost, the Court was asked whether national courts may declare Community acts invalid. It ruled that they may not, and it held a Commission decision on duty recovery invalid.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

The company Foto-Frost, an importer of photographic goods in Germany, bought prismatic binoculars made in the German Democratic Republic from traders in Denmark and the United Kingdom [1]. The goods were sent under the Community external transit procedure, which lets non-EU goods move between Member States without new customs formalities, from customs warehouses in Denmark and the Netherlands [1]. The competent customs offices first allowed the goods in duty free, because they originated in the German Democratic Republic [1]. After a check, the Hauptzollamt Lübeck-Ost, a German principal customs office, considered that customs duty was due [1]. It took the view that recovery of the duty was not appropriate, because the importer met the conditions of Article 5(2) of Regulation No 1697/79, but it had not itself waived recovery [1]. The amount exceeded 2000 ECU, so the office could not decide alone. Its request went through the Federal Minister for Finance to the Commission [1]. On 6 May 1983 the Commission decided that recovery could not be waived [1]. The Finanzgericht Hamburg then doubted that decision was valid and referred questions to the Court [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether a national court may itself declare an act of a Community institution invalid [1]. It also had to decide whether the Commission decision of 6 May 1983, which held that recovery could not be waived, was valid [1].

The outcome

The Court ruled that national courts have no jurisdiction themselves to declare acts of Community institutions invalid [1]. It held that all three conditions of Article 5(2) were met, so the importer was entitled to the waiver, and that the Commission decision was invalid [1]. Foto-Frost therefore won on the main point [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court began with Article 177 of the EEC Treaty, which allows courts to ask the Court for rulings on the validity of Community acts. The Treaty does not say whether national courts may declare such acts invalid themselves [1]. The Court held that national courts may consider validity and reject a challenge they find unfounded, but may not declare an act invalid [1]. Its reasons were uniform application of Community law and legal certainty, which divergent national rulings on validity would put at risk [1]. It also relied on the coherence of the system: Articles 173, 184 and 177 form a complete system of review, and Article 173 gives the Court exclusive power to declare an act void [1]. It added that the Court is in the best position to decide on validity, because Community institutions whose acts are challenged may take part and defend them [1]. The Court then examined the three conditions of Article 5(2) of Regulation No 1697/79 [1]. The first was met because the importer's declaration contained all the correct facts, and the post-clearance check revealed no new fact, so the error was the authorities' own [1]. The second was met because the importer could not reasonably detect the error, given uncertain case law and earlier exemptions [1]. The third was met because the Commission itself admitted that the declaration was correct [1]. The Court therefore held the Commission decision invalid [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the main lesson of the judgment concerns the division of powers. A national court may examine whether a Community act is valid and reject a challenge it finds unfounded, but it cannot itself declare the act invalid [1]. Only the Court of Justice can do that, because uniform application of Community law and legal certainty require it [1]. This is the Foto-Frost principle. On this reading, the judgment also shows how the three conditions of Article 5(2) of Regulation No 1697/79 work: once all three are fulfilled, the person liable is entitled to the waiver of recovery [1]. Later judgments have relied on the three conditions and on the holding [6][7]. The judgment does not settle how far a national court may go in urgent interim proceedings. It notes an exception for interim measures but does not examine it, because the referring court did not ask about it [1]. Nor does it answer the question on discretion, which the Court found did not call for a reply [1]. The Advocate General proposed that a national court facing doubts about validity should stay the proceedings and refer the matter to the Court [2]. That is the Advocate General's proposal, not a holding of the Court. This is an assessment, not advice, and it should not be used to predict the outcome of other cases.

How the sources fit together

Advocate General Mancini recommended that national courts have no power to declare Community acts invalid, and that a national court with doubts about validity should stay the proceedings and refer the matter to the Court [2]. The Court gave the same answer on the first question [1]. It noted an exception for interim proceedings without deciding it [1]. The three conditions of Article 5(2) of Regulation No 1697/79 were central to the second question [1]. Later judgments cite the case for those conditions: Binder quotes them [6], and Top Hit cites it for the entitlement to waiver [7]. Gebrüder Weis cites it in a passage on three concurrent conditions, although the excerpt is cut off [4]. Weber cites it for the Treaty's complete system of legal remedies [5]. In Mecanarte, the Portuguese Government relied on the case, and the Council also relied on it [3].

From the sources

The national courts have no jurisdiction themselves to declare that acts of community institutions are invalid [1]
The coherence of the system requires that where the validity of a community act is challenged before a national court the power to declare the act invalid must also be reserved to the court of justice [1]
That provision must be interpreted as meaning that if all those requirements are fulfilled the person liable is entitled to the waiver of the recovery of the duty in question [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-314/85: Judgment of the Court of 22 October 1987. — Foto-Frost v Hauptzollamt Lübeck-Ost. the judgment · 22 October 1987
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-314/85: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Mancini delivered on 19 May 1987. — Foto-Frost v Hauptzollamt Lübeck-Ost. the Advocate General's opinion · 19 May 1987
  3. Judgment in Case C-348/89: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 27 June 1991. — Mecanarte - Metalúrgica da Lagoa Ldª v Chefe do Serviço da Conferência Final da Alfândega do Porto. a later judgment that cites this case · 27 June 1991
  4. Judgment in Case C-292/91: Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 4 May 1993. — Gebrüder Weis GmbH v Hauptzollamt Würzburg. a later judgment that cites this case · 4 May 1993
  5. Judgment in Case C-314/91: Judgment of the Court of 23 March 1993. — Beate Weber v European Parliament. a later judgment that cites this case · 23 March 1993
  6. Judgment in Case C-161/88: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 12 July 1989. — Friedrich Binder GmbH & Co. KG v Hauptzollamt Bad Reichenhall. a later judgment that cites this case · 12 July 1989
  7. Judgment in Case C-378/87: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 23 May 1989. — Top Hit Holzvertrieb GmbH v Commission of the European Communities. a later judgment that cites this case · 23 May 1989