Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Mangold: age-based fixed-term contracts and the EU ban on age discrimination

Court of JusticeEmployment and social rightsJudgment in Case C-144/0422 November 2005

In Mangold, the Court asked whether German law allowing fixed-term contracts without reason for workers aged 52 and over breached EU law. It held that Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78 precludes such a rule, and national courts must set it aside.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

The worker, then 56, was hired on 26 June 2003 by a lawyer under a fixed-term contract running from 1 July 2003 to 28 February 2004 [1]. The contract relied on German law, Paragraph 14(3) of the TzBfG, which allowed fixed-term contracts without an objective reason for workers aged 52 and over [1]. An earlier version of that rule had set the age at 58, and a 2002 amendment lowered it to 52 [1]. The worker brought proceedings claiming that the rule breached EU law, and the German court referred questions to the Court of Justice [1]. The German court noted that the EU deadline for transposing the age directive into national law had not yet expired when the contract was signed [1]. The contract was the worker's only contract with that employer [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether the non-regression clause of the Framework Agreement on fixed-term work, and Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78 on age discrimination, prevent a national law that allows fixed-term contracts without restriction for workers aged 52 and over [1]. It also had to say what a national court must do if such a law conflicts with EU law [1].

The outcome

The Court did not decide the dispute itself, which is left to the national court [1]. It held that lowering the age threshold was not contrary to Clause 8(3) of the Framework Agreement, because the change was not connected to implementing that agreement [1]. It held that Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78 precludes the national rule, so on the age point the worker's position prevailed in principle [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first held that the referral was admissible. The national court is best placed to judge whether a ruling is needed, and the dispute was not fictitious just because both parties agreed on the outcome [1]. It did not answer the question on Clause 5 of the Framework Agreement, because that clause concerns successive contracts and this was a single contract [1]. On Clause 8(3), the non-regression clause, which bars using implementation of the agreement as a reason to lower worker protection, the Court held that a cut in protection is not prohibited where it is unconnected to implementing the agreement. The age threshold was lowered to encourage the employment of older people, so it was not contrary to that clause [1]. On Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78, the Court accepted that promoting the vocational integration of unemployed older workers is a legitimate aim [1]. But the law applied age alone to all workers aged 52 and over. It was not shown that an age threshold on its own was objectively necessary, so the rule went beyond what was appropriate and necessary [1]. The unexpired transposition deadline did not change this. During the transposition period, Member States must not take measures that seriously compromise the result a directive prescribes [1]. Finally, the Court held that non-discrimination on grounds of age is a general principle of Community law, and the national court must set aside conflicting national provisions [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment shows that EU age discrimination law can override a national rule that sets an age threshold for fixed-term contracts, at least where the rule is not justified as Article 6(1) requires [1]. The Court stressed that justification must consider more than age alone, such as the structure of the labour market or the worker's personal situation [1]. The judgment also treats non-discrimination on grounds of age as a general principle of EU law, not only as a rule of Directive 2000/78 [1]. This suggests that a national court may need to set aside conflicting national law, even before the transposition deadline has passed [1]. The judgment does not itself decide the dispute, and it does not say how the German court should apply the rule to this contract [1]. It also does not hold that every age-based rule is unlawful. The Court accepted that promoting older workers' employment is a legitimate aim, and that Member States have broad discretion in employment policy [1]. The Advocate General discussed whether the principle could be relied on directly between private parties, but the judgment itself rests on the national court's duty to set aside conflicting rules [2][1]. This is an assessment only, not legal advice, and it should not be used to predict the outcome of other cases.

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General proposed that Clause 8(3) did not prevent the lowering of the age threshold, because the change was based on employment policy rather than on the directive [2]. The Court reached the same answer on that point [1]. On Clause 5, the Advocate General proposed that the Court decline to rule because the contract was a single contract [2]. The Court also did not answer that question, finding it irrelevant to the dispute [1]. The main issue was Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78, which the Court applied and found to preclude the national rule [1]. A later judgment cites the case for the principle that Directive 2000/78 gives concrete expression to a general principle of EU law, so its protection does not go beyond that principle [3]. Another later judgment cites it for the Court's duty to give the national court the criteria needed to assess compatibility with general principles [4].

From the sources

The principle of non-discrimination on grounds of age must thus be regarded as a general principle of Community law. [1]
Such national legislation cannot, therefore, be justified under Article 6(1) of Directive 2000/78. [1]
the scope of the protection conferred by the directive does not go beyond that afforded by that principle. [3]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-144/04: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 22 November 2005. — Werner Mangold v Rüdiger Helm. the judgment · 22 November 2005
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-144/04: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Tizzano delivered on 30 June 2005. — Werner Mangold v Rüdiger Helm. the Advocate General's opinion · 30 June 2005
  3. Judgment in Case C-441/14: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 19 April 2016. — Dansk Industri (DI), acting on behalf of Ajos A/S v Estate of Karsten Eigil Rasmussen. a later judgment that cites this case · 19 April 2016
  4. Judgment in Case C-427/06: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 23 September 2008. — Birgit Bartsch v Bosch und Siemens Hausgeräte (BSH) Altersfürsorge GmbH. a later judgment that cites this case · 23 September 2008