Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Laval: can unions use blockades to force a foreign firm into Swedish pay deals?

Court of JusticeEmployment and social rightsJudgment in Case C-341/0518 December 2007

In Laval, the question was whether Swedish trade unions could blockade a Latvian firm to force it to sign a Swedish collective agreement and set pay. The Court said EU law precludes this kind of blockade.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

Laval un Partneri, a Latvian company, posted about 35 workers to Sweden in 2004. They worked on school buildings in Vaxholm through its Swedish subsidiary, Baltic [1]. Laval had signed collective agreements in Latvia but was not bound by any Swedish agreement [1]. Swedish building unions asked Laval to sign the Swedish building-sector collective agreement and to guarantee an hourly wage of SEK 145 [1]. Swedish law does not set minimum rates of pay. Pay is negotiated between employers and unions [1]. When talks failed, the unions blockaded the site from 2 November 2004, and an electricians' union joined in sympathy action [1]. The posted workers went home, and the subsidiary later went bankrupt [1]. Laval sued the unions in the Swedish Labour Court, which referred questions to the Court of Justice [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether EU rules on the freedom to provide services and on posted workers allow trade unions in a Member State to use blockades to force a foreign provider to negotiate pay and sign a collective agreement [1]. It also had to decide whether Swedish rules that ignore collective agreements already binding a foreign firm are compatible with the EU ban on discrimination [1].

The outcome

The Court held that Article 49 EC and Directive 96/71 preclude a trade union, in a Member State where the relevant terms are set by law, from using blockades to force a foreign service provider to negotiate pay and sign a collective agreement with more favourable terms [1]. It also held that Articles 49 EC and 50 EC preclude a ban on collective action from being conditional on terms to which national law applies directly [1]. Laval, the posting firm, won on both points [1].

The Court’s reasoning

Directive 96/71 sets a core of mandatory minimum protection that host states may require posting firms to observe, but it leaves the content of those rules to the Member States [1]. Under the directive, the protection a host state can require is limited, in principle, to the listed matters, unless workers already enjoy better terms at home [1]. Sweden does not set minimum pay by the means the directive allows, so it cannot require foreign firms to meet pay rates set through case-by-case negotiation [1]. The right to collective action is a fundamental right, but it does not take the case outside EU law, and it must be reconciled with free movement and with proportionality [1]. The blockades restricted the freedom to provide services [1]. Protecting workers can be an overriding reason of public interest, but the blockades could not be justified where the national context lacked sufficiently precise and accessible rules on minimum pay [1]. On the second question, the Court said that a rule ignoring existing collective agreements treats posting firms in the same way as national firms that have not concluded an agreement. Such rules discriminate by ignoring the agreements the foreign firms are already bound by, and the aims given for them are not public policy grounds [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment establishes that EU free movement rules limit what trade unions may do against a firm that posts workers to another Member State [1]. The principle is that collective action, including blockades, can restrict the freedom to provide services and must be justified and proportionate [1]. Protecting workers is a recognised aim, but on this reading the judgment indicates that it cannot justify demands beyond the minimum protection set by the directive, especially where the host state's rules on minimum pay are not clear and accessible [1]. The judgment also indicates that a host state cannot ignore collective agreements a posting firm already has at home without facing a discrimination finding [1]. It does not define which forms of collective action are lawful in other circumstances [1]. This assessment is not legal advice, and it does not predict how other cases will be decided [1].

How the sources fit together

Advocate General Mengozzi's opinion framed the case as a balance between the right to collective action and the freedom to provide services, and it stressed proportionality [2]. The Court accepted that collective action is a fundamental right but held that EU law still applies to it [1]. The sources provided do not allow a full comparison of the opinion with the judgment on every point. Later judgments cite this case for the test that a restriction on the freedom to provide services must pursue a legitimate objective, be justified by overriding reasons of public interest, be suitable, and not go beyond what is necessary [3][6]. Another judgment cites it for the point that Member States may freely define the content of minimum protection [5]. Laval is also cited on the compatibility of industrial action with the freedom to provide services [4].

From the sources

is liable to make it less attractive, or more difficult, for such undertakings to carry out construction work in Sweden [1]
fail to take into account, irrespective of their content, collective agreements to which undertakings that post workers to Sweden are already bound [1]
a lack of provisions, of any kind, which are sufficiently precise and accessible [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-341/05: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 18 December 2007. — Laval un Partneri Ltd v Svenska Byggnadsarbetareförbundet, Svenska Byggnadsarbetareförbundets avdelning 1, Bygge the judgment · 18 December 2007
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-341/05: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Mengozzi delivered on 23 May 2007. — Laval un Partneri Ltd v Svenska Byggnadsarbetareförbundet, Svenska Byggnadsarbetar the Advocate General's opinion · 23 May 2007
  3. Judgment in Case C-330/07: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 4 December 2008. — Jobra Vermögensverwaltungs-Gesellschaft mbH v Finanzamt Amstetten Melk Scheibbs. a later judgment that cites this case · 4 December 2008
  4. Judgment in Case C-83/13: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber), 8 July 2014. — Fonnship A/S v Svenska Transportarbetareförbundet and Facket för Service och Kommunikation (SEKO) and Svenska Transporta a later judgment that cites this case · 8 July 2014
  5. Judgment in Case C-522/12: Judgment of the Court (Seventh Chamber), 7 November 2013. — Tevfik Isbir v DB Services GmbH. a later judgment that cites this case · 7 November 2013
  6. Judgment in Case C-265/12: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber), 18 July 2013. — Citroën Belux NV v Federatie voor Verzekerings- en Financiële Tussenpersonen (FvF). a later judgment that cites this case · 18 July 2013