Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Google Spain: search engines can be ordered to delist outdated personal data

Court of JusticeData protection and privacyJudgment in Case C-131/1213 May 2014

In Google Spain, the Court asked whether a search engine must remove links to lawful but outdated pages about a person. It said yes where the data are inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, unless the public interest outweighs privacy.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

A Spanish national living in Spain complained to the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD) on 5 March 2010. He complained against the newspaper La Vanguardia, Google Spain and Google Inc. [1] A search for his name returned links to two newspaper pages from 1998. They carried an announcement of a real-estate auction linked to attachment proceedings (a seizure of assets) for social security debts. He said the proceedings had been fully resolved years earlier and that the reference was now irrelevant. [1] The AEPD rejected the complaint against the newspaper, because the publication was legally justified and ordered by the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs. It upheld the complaint against Google and ordered Google Inc. to withdraw the data from its index and block future access. [1] Google Search is run by Google Inc., which is based in the United States. Google Spain, a subsidiary in Madrid, promotes and sells advertising space. [1] Both companies appealed to the Audiencia Nacional, which referred questions to the Court. [1]

The question

The Court had to decide three things. First, whether a search engine's activity counts as 'processing of personal data' by a 'controller' under Directive 95/46 [1]. Second, whether Spanish data protection law applies to a US-based operator with a Spanish advertising subsidiary [1]. Third, whether and when the operator must remove links to lawful third-party pages about a person, even if that person merely wants the information forgotten [1].

The outcome

The Court answered yes to each point. The search engine operator is a controller, and Spanish law applies because of the Spanish advertising subsidiary [1]. The operator must remove the links if the conditions are met, even if the page itself is lawful and stays online [1]. For the data subject in this case, the Court found a right to have the links removed, subject to a check by the national court for a preponderant public interest. The data subject therefore largely won against Google [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first held that a search engine collects, records, organises, stores and makes available data. This is 'processing of personal data' under Article 2(b), even if the data were already published and unaltered [1]. The operator decides the purposes and means of that processing, so it is the 'controller' under Article 2(d) [1]. On territory, Article 4(1)(a) only requires that processing take place 'in the context of the activities' of an establishment, not that the establishment carry it out itself. The words cannot be read restrictively [1]. A subsidiary that promotes and sells advertising space in a Member State is enough, because advertising and the search engine are inextricably linked [1]. On removal, all processing must meet the data quality rules in Article 6 and a legitimacy ground in Article 7. Article 7(f) requires a balance that takes account of Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter [1]. Search engine processing is additional to the publisher's. A name search gives a structured overview that allows a detailed profile of a person [1]. The data subject need not first approach the publisher. Information is easily copied, publishers may be outside EU law, and a publisher may rely on a journalistic exemption [1]. Even accurate data can become incompatible with the directive over time if they are inadequate, irrelevant, no longer relevant or excessive [1]. Prejudice to the person is not required. The person's rights override, as a rule, the operator's economic interest and the public's interest, unless the person's role in public life justifies public access [1].

What the judgment means

This section is an assessment. On this reading, the judgment makes the search engine operator responsible in its own right for name-based search results. That responsibility is separate from the publisher's [1]. The Court describes the outcome as a balancing exercise, not an automatic right to erasure. The person's rights override 'as a rule', but not where there is a preponderant public interest, for example because of the person's role in public life [1]. On this reading, the judgment does not require the original web page to be changed or removed. It speaks only of removing links from the list of results shown after a search on the person's name, even where the page itself is lawful [1]. It also gives no fixed time limit. In this case the Court pointed to the sensitivity of the information and the 16 years that had passed, and it left the final check to the referring court [1]. The ruling is based on Directive 95/46, which the Advocate General noted the Commission had proposed to replace with a regulation [1][2]. The later judgments in the sources repeat its reasoning on the added effect of search engines [4][5] and on a broad reading of the territorial rule [6]. On this reading, the reasoning therefore keeps weight, although the sources do not show every later use.

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General proposed that the 'centre of gravity' of a dispute, such as the data subject's residence, should not on its own make the directive apply [2]. The Court did not need to rule on that point, because the Spanish subsidiary's advertising activity was enough [1]. The case turned on Articles 2(b) and (d), 4(1)(a), 12(b) and 14(a) of the directive and Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter [1]. Later judgments cite it often. A 2019 judgment on Google and CNIL relies on its finding that search and advertising activities are inextricably linked [3]. A 2022 judgment repeats that search engine processing is distinct from and additional to the publisher's [4]. Another 2019 judgment repeats the operator's duty to act within its responsibilities, powers and capabilities [5]. Weltimmo repeats the broad reading of 'in the context of the activities of an establishment' and the test for 'establishment' [6]. Manni cites its statements on data quality and legitimacy [7].

From the sources

the information and links concerned in the list of results must be erased. [1]
effective and complete protection of data users could not be achieved if the latter had to obtain first or in parallel the erasure of the information relating to them from the publishers of websites. [1]
the activities of the operator of the search engine and those of its establishment situated in the Member State concerned are inextricably linked [1]
within the framework of his responsibilities, powers and capabilities, that the activity meets the requirements of Directive 95/46 [5]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-131/12: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber), 13 May 2014. — Google Spain SL and Google Inc. v Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD) and Mario Costeja González. the judgment · 13 May 2014
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-131/12: Opinion of Advocate General Jääskinen delivered on 25 June 2013. — Google Spain SL and Google Inc. v Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD) an the Advocate General's opinion · 25 June 2013
  3. Judgment in Case C-507/17: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 24 September 2019. — Google LLC, successor in law to Google Inc. v Commission nationale de l'informatique et des libertés (CNIL). a later judgment that cites this case · 24 September 2019
  4. Judgment in Case C-460/20: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 December 2022. — TU and RE v Google LLC. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 December 2022
  5. Judgment in Case C-136/17: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 24 September 2019. — GC and Others v Commission nationale de l'informatique et des libertés (CNIL). a later judgment that cites this case · 24 September 2019
  6. Judgment in Case C-230/14: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 1 October 2015. — Weltimmo s.r.o. v Nemzeti Adatvédelmi és Információszabadság Hatóság. a later judgment that cites this case · 1 October 2015
  7. Judgment in Case C-398/15: Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 9 March 2017. — Camera di Commercio, Industria, Artigianato e Agricoltura di Lecce v Salvatore Manni. a later judgment that cites this case · 9 March 2017