Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Francovich: must a country pay for failing to put an EU worker-protection rule into law?

Court of JusticeEmployment and social rightsJudgment in Case C-6/9019 November 1991

The Francovich judgment asked whether workers could enforce an unimplemented EU directive directly against the State. It ruled they could not do so here, but that a Member State must make good loss caused to individuals by its failure to implement a directive.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

The case concerns Directive 80/987/EEC, which requires Member States to put in place guarantees for employees' unpaid wages when their employer becomes insolvent. Italy did not adopt the measures needed to implement the directive by 23 October 1983, and the Court had already confirmed this failure in an earlier judgment [1][2]. One worker had received only sporadic wage payments. He obtained a court order for about LIT 6 million, but the bailiff's attempt to enforce it failed [1]. A second group of 34 employees was owed more than LIT 253 million by a company declared insolvent in 1985. More than five years later they had received nothing, and the receiver said even a partial payment was very unlikely [1]. Both groups asked the Italian State to provide the guarantee under the directive or, alternatively, to pay compensation. The two national courts asked the Court of Justice whether they could do so [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether workers could rely directly on the wage-guarantee provisions of Directive 80/987/EEC against Italy because it had not implemented them on time. It also had to decide whether Italy had to make good the loss caused to the workers by that failure [1][2].

The outcome

The Court ruled that the directive's provisions could not be enforced directly against Italy, because they did not identify who had to provide the guarantee [1]. It also ruled that a Member State must make good loss and damage caused to individuals by failing to implement the directive [1]. The workers therefore won on compensation but not on direct enforcement, so the State lost in part [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first asked whether the directive's wage-guarantee provisions could be relied on directly against Italy. It found that the provisions identified who was entitled to the guarantee and what the guarantee covered, but not who had to provide it. The guarantee was to be provided by guarantee institutions, and the State could not be treated as liable merely because it had missed the deadline for implementation [1]. Workers therefore could not enforce those rights against the State in national courts [1]. On liability, the Court held that the full effectiveness of Community rules would be impaired if individuals could not obtain redress for breaches for which a Member State is responsible [1]. It said that the principle of State liability is inherent in the system of the Treaty, and that Article 5 of the Treaty requires Member States to take all appropriate measures, including nullifying the unlawful consequences of a breach [1]. Liability for failing to implement a directive depends on three conditions: the directive must grant rights to individuals, the content of those rights must be identifiable from the directive, and there must be a causal link between the breach and the loss [1]. The Court applied these conditions to the case. The breach had already been confirmed in an earlier judgment, the directive granted employees a right to a guarantee of unpaid wages, and the content of that right could be identified from the directive [1]. National law then sets the detailed rules, but those rules must not be less favourable than for similar domestic claims or make reparation virtually impossible or excessively difficult [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment's main significance is that it creates a route to compensation where an EU directive has not been implemented and its provisions cannot be enforced directly against the State [1]. The Court grounded that route in the system of the Treaty and in Article 5, which requires Member States to nullify the unlawful consequences of a breach [1]. Later judgments have described a similar route: a party harmed by national law that conflicts with EU law, and which cannot rely on the directive against the other party, may seek compensation from the Member State [4][6]. On this reading, this suggests the principle has been used beyond the facts of the original case, but the sources do not show how widely it applies in each situation. The judgment does not set the amount of compensation, which is left to the national courts under national rules, subject to the limits the Court set [1]. It also does not decide when a directive can be enforced directly between private parties. It held only that the directive's provisions could not be relied on against the State in this case because they did not identify the liable party [1]. The sources do not show how the principle will apply in other areas. This assessment is not legal advice and does not predict how other cases will be decided.

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General proposed that the directive's provisions were not sufficiently precise and unconditional to give individuals enforceable rights [2]. The Court reached the same practical result by a different route. It found the provisions precise as to who was entitled and what the guarantee covered, but held they could not be enforced because they did not identify the person liable to pay [1]. The Advocate General also proposed that a Member State could be liable where the Court had declared it in default [2]. The Court held that a Member State must make good the loss caused by failure to transpose the directive, without relying on a test of sufficiently serious breach [1]. Later judgments cite the case for the reparation route: one says a harmed party can rely on it to seek compensation from the Member State [4], and another says the same [6]. Others cite it for the directive's scope [5] or its provisions [3]. A 1997 judgment on the same directive addresses the extent of reparation in related proceedings [7].

From the sources

A Member State is required to make good loss and damage caused to individuals by failure to transpose Directive 80/987/EEC. [1]
the principle whereby a State must be liable for loss and damage caused to individuals as a result of breaches of Community law for which the State can be held responsible is inherent in the system of the Treaty. [1]
the persons concerned cannot enforce those rights against the State before the national courts where no implementing measures are adopted within the prescribed period [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-6/90: Judgment of the Court of 19 November 1991. — Andrea Francovich and Danila Bonifaci and others v Italian Republic. the judgment · 19 November 1991
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-6/90: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Mischo delivered on 28 May 1991. — Andrea Francovich and Danila Bonifaci and others v Italian Republic. the Advocate General's opinion · 28 May 1991
  3. Judgment in Case C-261/95: Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 10 July 1997. — Rosalba Palmisani v Istituto nazionale della previdenza sociale (INPS). a later judgment that cites this case · 10 July 1997
  4. Judgment in Case C-122/17: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 7 August 2018. — David Smith v Patrick Meade and Others. a later judgment that cites this case · 7 August 2018
  5. Judgment in Case C-292/14: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 25 February 2016. — Elliniko Dimosio v Stefanos Stroumpoulis and Others. a later judgment that cites this case · 25 February 2016
  6. Judgment in Case C-282/10: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber), 24 January 2012. — Maribel Dominguez v Centre informatique du Centre Ouest Atlantique and Préfet de la région Centre. a later judgment that cites this case · 24 January 2012
  7. Judgment in Case C-94/95: Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 10 July 1997. — Danila Bonifaci and others (C-94/95) and Wanda Berto and others (C-95/95) v Istituto nazionale della previdenza socia another EU document with similar content · 10 July 1997