Costa v ENEL: EU Treaty rules can override later conflicting national laws
In Costa v ENEL, the Court was asked whether certain EEC Treaty articles give individuals rights that national courts must protect. The Court held that Article 53 and Article 37(2) do, and that Community law cannot be overridden by later national laws.
The case
The case began before a court in Milan, Italy, in a dispute between an individual and ENEL, the Italian national electricity board. [1] The party challenging the position argued that Italian Law No 1643 of 6 December 1962, and the presidential decrees made under it, infringed Articles 102, 93, 53 and 37 of the EEC Treaty. [1] That law nationalised the electricity industry in Italy. [2] The Milan court stayed the proceedings and referred questions on the interpretation of those articles to the Court of Justice under Article 177, the procedure for preliminary rulings. [1] Under that procedure, a national court asks the Court how EU law should be read, and the national court then decides the dispute itself. [1] The Italian Government argued that the request was inadmissible because the national court only had to apply Italian law. [1]
The question
The Court had to decide whether it could answer questions on the interpretation of Treaty articles when the national court had to apply national law. It also had to decide whether Articles 102, 93, 53 and 37 create individual rights that national courts must protect. [1]
The outcome
The Court held that the questions were admissible in so far as they concerned the interpretation of the Treaty. [1] It ruled that Article 102 and the relevant parts of Article 93 contain no provisions capable of creating such individual rights, while Article 53 and Article 37(2) do create them. [1] The Court did not decide the dispute itself, and it left the decision on costs to the Milan court. [1]
The Court’s reasoning
Article 177 does not allow the Court to apply the Treaty to a specific case or to rule on the validity of national law, but the Court can extract the interpretation questions from a badly worded national question. [1] The Court stressed a clear separation of functions between national courts and the Court of Justice, so the Court cannot investigate the facts or criticise the reasons for the request. [1] The Court held that the EEC Treaty created its own legal system, which became part of the legal systems of the Member States and which their courts must apply. [1] Member States limited their sovereign rights by creating a body of law binding on their nationals and on themselves. [1] Because of this, a later unilateral national measure cannot take precedence over Community law, which is an independent source of law. [1] For Article 102, the Court held that the duty to consult the Commission binds States but creates no individual rights. [1] For Article 93, the obligations bind States and create no individual rights, apart from the final provision of Article 93(3), which was not in question. [1] For Article 53, the Court held that the duty not to introduce new restrictions is legally complete and can produce direct effects, so it creates individual rights. [1] For Article 37(2), the Court held that the absolute prohibition on new discriminatory measures creates individual rights that national courts must protect. [1]
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment establishes that EU law takes precedence over later conflicting national laws, and that some Treaty provisions can be relied on by individuals in national courts without further national measures. [1] The Court's reasoning rests on the idea that the Member States permanently limited their sovereign rights when they joined the Community. [1] On this reading, the judgment does not decide whether the Italian law actually breached the Treaty, because the Court left the application of the Treaty to the facts to the national court. [1] It also does not decide how the other articles apply to any specific electricity monopoly, since the Court only addressed the four provisions referred to it. [1] The Court noted that whether an economic activity falls under Article 37 depends on the facts and must be assessed by the national court. [1] This is an assessment, not legal advice, and the judgment should be read with its precise wording and limits in mind.
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General's opinion argued that Article 102 and Article 93 are not self-executing, meaning they cannot be relied on in national courts without further national measures, and that Article 53 is self-executing. [2] The Court agreed on Articles 102, 93 and 53. [1] The opinion, as available in the sources, breaks off during its analysis of Article 37, so it does not show what the Advocate General proposed on that article. [2] The Court held that Article 37(2) creates individual rights. [1] Later judgments cite this case: one quotes the summary on the limits of Article 177, and another quotes the principle that a Member State obligation can produce direct effects and create rights that national courts must protect. [3][4][5] Two later judgments cite this judgment on the prohibition on implementation in Article 93(3), but the extract stops before the holding is stated. [6][7]
From the sources
The law stemming from the treaty, an independent source of law, could not, because of its special and original nature, be overridden by domestic legal provisions, however framed [1]
Article 53 constitutes a community rule capable of creating individual rights which national courts must protect [1]
Article 102 contains no provisions which are capable of creating individual rights which national courts must protect [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-6/64: Judgment of the Court of 15 July 1964. — Flaminio Costa v E.N.E.L. the judgment · 15 July 1964
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-6/64: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Lagrange delivered on 25 June 1964. — Flaminio Costa v E.N.E.L. the Advocate General's opinion · 25 June 1964
- Judgment in Case C-20/64: Judgment of the Court of 4 February 1965. — SARL Albatros v Société des pétroles et des combustibles liquides (Sopéco). a later judgment that cites this case · 4 February 1965
- Judgment in Case C-56/65: Judgment of the Court of 30 June 1966. — Société Technique Minière (L.T.M.) v Maschinenbau Ulm GmbH (M.B.U.). a later judgment that cites this case · 30 June 1966
- Judgment in Case C-57/65: Judgment of the Court of 16 June 1966. — Alfons Lütticke GmbH v Hauptzollamt Sarrelouis. a later judgment that cites this case · 16 June 1966
- Judgment in Case C-120/73: Judgment of the Court of 11 December 1973. — Gebrüder Lorenz GmbH v Federal Republic of Germany and Land Rheinland-Pfalz. a later judgment that cites this case · 11 December 1973
- Judgment in Case C-121/73: Judgment of the Court of 11 December 1973. — Markmann KG v Federal Republic of Germany and Land Schleswig-Holstein. a later judgment that cites this case · 11 December 1973