Can a country demand a retrial before surrendering someone convicted in absentia?
In Melloni, the Court asked whether a court may make a European arrest warrant conditional on a retrial for a person convicted in absentia. It ruled that it may not, and that Article 53 of the Charter does not let a state add that condition.
The case
The applicant was tried in Italy in his absence for bankruptcy fraud and sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment. He had appointed two lawyers, who were notified of the trial and defended him at first instance and on appeal [1]. In 2004 Italy issued a European arrest warrant to enforce the sentence [1]. Spain arrested the applicant in 2008 and ordered his surrender to Italy [1]. The applicant challenged this before the Spanish Tribunal Constitucional, arguing that surrender should depend on a right to a retrial in Italy [1]. That court asked the Court of Justice whether the EU framework decision, as amended in 2009, allowed such a condition [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether Article 4a(1) of Framework Decision 2002/584, a binding EU law instrument on surrender between Member States, stops a judicial authority from making surrender conditional on a retrial [1]. It also had to decide whether that provision fits the Charter's rights to a fair trial and rights of defence, and whether Article 53 of the Charter lets a Member State apply a higher national standard [1].
The outcome
The Court ruled that Article 4a(1) precludes making surrender conditional on a retrial in the situations listed in that provision [1]. It also held that the provision is compatible with Articles 47 and 48(2) of the Charter, and that Article 53 does not allow a Member State to impose such a condition [1]. The answers favoured surrender, so the Spanish court could not rely on the retrial condition [1].
The Court’s reasoning
The Court began with the wording of Article 4a(1). It gives an optional ground for refusal where a person did not appear at trial, but lists four situations where refusal is not allowed [1]. Two of these fit the case: a person who was summoned or otherwise informed of the trial, and a person who, aware of the trial, gave a mandate to a legal counsellor who then defended him at trial [1]. In those situations, the executing authority cannot make surrender conditional on a retrial [1]. The Court also looked at purpose. The 2009 amendment replaced the older Article 5(1), which had let the executing authority require assurances of a retrial. The EU legislature wanted clear, common grounds for refusal, so the list is exhaustive [1]. On the Charter, the Court held that the right to be present at trial is essential but not absolute. It can be waived, and no breach arises where the person was informed of the trial or was defended by a chosen lawyer [1]. Article 4a therefore respects Articles 47 and 48(2) [1]. On Article 53, the Court said that allowing a state to apply a higher national standard would undermine the primacy of EU law and mutual trust [1]. Rules of national law, even constitutional ones, cannot undermine the effectiveness of EU law [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment's main lesson is that, where Article 4a(1) applies, an executing court cannot add a retrial condition to the surrender of a person convicted in absentia [1]. The case is cited in later judgments under the name Melloni for the principle of mutual recognition with limited grounds for refusal [4]. On this reading, it also shows that a Member State cannot use Article 53 of the Charter to apply a higher national standard that would override EU rules [1][2]. The judgment does not decide cases outside the four situations in Article 4a(1), and it does not settle what a retrial in a particular state must involve [1]. It also does not give general guidance on other kinds of cases where a person was not informed of the trial and had no lawyer [1]. Later judgments cite it on the primacy of EU law, which shows how it has been used beyond criminal cooperation [5][6]. This is an assessment, not legal advice, and it does not predict how other cases will be decided.
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General read Article 4a(1) as excluding a general retrial condition in the listed situations, and the Court's reading follows that analysis [2][1]. Both the opinion and the judgment turn on Article 4a(1) and on Article 53 of the Charter [1][2]. Later judgments cite the case for the harmonised conditions for convictions in absentia [3], for the limited grounds for refusal [4], and for the rule that national standards cannot undermine EU law [5][6].
From the sources
the execution of a European arrest warrant issued for the purposes of executing a sentence conditional upon the conviction rendered in absentia being open to review in the issuing Member State [1]
would undermine the principles of mutual trust and recognition which that decision purports to uphold and would, therefore, compromise the efficacy of that framework decision. [1]
The new Article 4a effects a harmonisation of the conditions of execution of a European arrest warrant in the event of a conviction rendered in absentia [3]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-399/11: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber), 26 February 2013. — Stefano Melloni v Ministerio Fiscal. the judgment · 26 February 2013
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-399/11: Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 2 October 2012. — Stefano Melloni v Ministerio Fiscal. the Advocate General's opinion · 2 October 2012
- Judgment in Case C-416/20: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 17 December 2020. — TR v Generalstaatsanwaltschaft Hamburg. a later judgment that cites this case · 17 December 2020
- Judgment in Case C-237/15: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 16 July 2015. — Minister for Justice and Equality v Francis Lanigan. a later judgment that cites this case · 16 July 2015
- Judgment in Case C-469/17: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 29 July 2019. — Funke Medien NRW GmbH v Bundesrepublik Deutschland. a later judgment that cites this case · 29 July 2019
- Judgment in Case C-476/17: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 29 July 2019. — Pelham GmbH and Others v Ralf Hütter and Florian Schneider-Esleben. a later judgment that cites this case · 29 July 2019