Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Can a country be liable when its highest court wrongly applies EU law?

Court of JusticeEmployment and social rightsJudgment in Case C-224/0130 September 2003

The Köbler judgment asked whether a Member State must pay damages when its highest court wrongly applies EU law. The Court said such liability is possible in principle, but only if the court's error is manifest, and found that the error in this case was not manifest.

Read the full judgment

En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

The applicant has worked since 1986 as an ordinary university professor in Innsbruck, Austria, under a public-law contract with the Austrian State.[1] Austrian law granted a special length-of-service increment only to professors with 15 years' service at Austrian universities. Service at universities in other Member States did not count.[1] In 1996 the applicant asked for the increment. He argued that this condition was indirect discrimination against workers who move between Member States.[1] The Verwaltungsgerichtshof, Austria's supreme administrative court, first referred questions to the Court. After the Court's Registry asked whether it still wished to pursue the reference, it withdrew the reference in 1998. It then held that the increment was a loyalty bonus that could justify the difference, and dismissed the claim.[1] The applicant then sued the Republic of Austria for damages, arguing that this ruling breached directly applicable EU law.[1]

The question

The Court had to decide whether a Member State can be liable for damage caused by a decision of its highest court that breaches EU law. It also had to decide whether the rule counting only Austrian university service was compatible with the free movement of workers.[1]

The outcome

The Court held that a Member State can be liable for a breach by a court of last instance, but only where the breach is sufficiently serious, meaning manifest. On the facts, the error was not manifest, so no liability arose.[1] The Court also held that Article 48 of the EC Treaty and Article 7(1) of Regulation No 1612/68 preclude the grant of such an increment, because it impedes freedom of movement for workers and cannot be justified by its loyalty purpose.[1] The worker therefore lost the damages claim, while Austria lost on the substantive EU law question.[1]

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first held that the principle that Member States must make good damage caused by breaches of EU law is inherent in the Treaty system and applies to any state authority, including a court of last instance.[1] Individuals must be able to obtain redress for a final judicial decision that cannot otherwise be corrected.[1] Res judicata does not prevent this, because a damages action seeks reparation rather than revision of the judgment.[1] Judicial independence is not put at risk, because liability concerns the State, not the judge personally.[1] Each Member State designates the competent court.[1] The Court then restated three conditions: the rule must confer rights on individuals, the breach must be sufficiently serious, and there must be a direct causal link.[1] For a court of last instance, liability arises only where the court manifestly infringed the applicable law. The national court must weigh factors such as the clarity of the rule, whether the error was intentional or excusable, and any failure to refer a question to the Court.[1] In any event, an infringement is sufficiently serious where the decision was made in manifest breach of the Court's case-law.[1] On the substance, the Court found that the increment was likely to impede freedom of movement and was not justified by a pressing public interest.[1] However, the error was not manifest: EU law did not expressly cover the point, the answer was not in the case-law, and the court had misread an earlier judgment.[1] The Court also said the court should have kept its reference open.[1]

What the judgment means

On this reading, Köbler is significant because it confirms that the State liability principle can reach decisions of a court of last instance, not only acts of the legislature or the administration.[1] The Court made clear that such liability is possible only in exceptional cases, where the error is manifest. On this reading, this high threshold is central to how far the ruling reaches.[1] The judgment does not set the amount of damages, does not decide which court hears such claims beyond saying that national law designates it, and does not say that a court's error automatically creates liability.[1] Later judgments cite paragraph 51 and state that liability for a final decision is not precluded by res judicata, while national law may allow less strict conditions.[3] Other later judgments repeat that liability can be incurred only where the court has manifestly infringed the applicable law.[4][7] On this reading, these references show that the principle is used as a reference point, but the sources do not show how the test has been applied in other individual cases.[4][6]

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General, Mr Léger, proposed that the principle of State liability extend to decisions of supreme courts, and that the first question be answered in the affirmative.[2] The Court followed that view on the principle, while setting a threshold of manifest breach for courts of last instance.[1][2] The Advocate General noted that Austrian law expressly excludes State liability for decisions of supreme courts.[2] The case turned on Article 48 of the EC Treaty on freedom of movement for workers and Article 7(1) of Regulation No 1612/68.[1] Later judgments rely on the Köbler principle and the manifest-breach test, including a 2016 judgment on Slovak courts [4], a 2019 judgment on Hungarian courts [3], and a 2026 Grand Chamber judgment [7]. A 2020 judgment on a German Land discusses the case mainly for its loyalty-bonus facts [5].

From the sources

In any event, an infringement of Community law will be sufficiently serious where the decision concerned was made in manifest breach of the case-law of the Court in the matter [1]
State liability for an infringement of Community law by a decision of a national court adjudicating at last instance can be incurred only in the exceptional case where the court has manifestly infringed the applicable law. [1]
the obstacle which it entails clearly cannot be justified in the light of such an objective [1]
Since an infringement of those rights by a final decision of such a court cannot thereafter normally be corrected, individuals cannot be deprived of the possibility of rendering the State liable [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-224/01: Judgment of the Court of 30 September 2003. — Gerhard Köbler v Republik Österreich. the judgment · 30 September 2003
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-224/01: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Léger delivered on 8 April 2003. — Gerhard Köbler v Republik Österreich. the Advocate General's opinion · 8 April 2003
  3. Judgment in Case C-620/17: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 29 July 2019. — Hochtief Solutions AG Magyarországi Fióktelepe v Fővárosi Törvényszék. a later judgment that cites this case · 29 July 2019
  4. Judgment in Case C-168/15: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 28 July 2016. — Milena Tomášová v Slovenská republika - Ministerstvo spravodlivosti SR and Pohotovosť s.r.o. a later judgment that cites this case · 28 July 2016
  5. Judgment in Case C-710/18: Judgment of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 23 April 2020. — WN v Land Niedersachsen. a later judgment that cites this case · 23 April 2020
  6. Judgment in Case C-163/24: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 September 2026. — BX v Statul Român – Ministerul Finanţelor Publice and Curtea de Apel Bucureşti. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 September 2026
  7. Judgment in Case C-293/24: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 September 2026. — João Filipe Ferreira da Silva e Brito and Others v Estado português. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 September 2026