Åkerberg Fransson: tax surcharges, criminal charges and the EU Charter
In Åkerberg Fransson, the Court was asked whether the EU Charter bars a criminal prosecution for false VAT information after a tax surcharge. It said no, if the surcharge is not criminal in nature; the national court decides that.
The case
The defendant was a self-employed worker whose main activities were fishing and selling white fish [2]. He was summoned before the Haparanda District Court on 9 June 2009 on charges of serious tax offences [1]. He was accused of giving false information in his tax returns for 2004 and 2005, which exposed the Swedish state to a loss of income tax and VAT revenue [1]. The VAT part was SEK 60 000 for 2004 and SEK 87 550 for 2005 [1]. He was also charged with failing to declare employers' contributions [1]. Earlier, on 24 May 2007, the Swedish Tax Board had ordered him to pay tax surcharges for both years [1]. He did not challenge them before the administrative courts, and the time limits expired on 31 December 2010 and 31 December 2011 [1]. The surcharges rested on the same false information as the prosecution [1]. The district court therefore asked whether the charges had to be dismissed because he had already been punished for the same acts [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether the Charter's ban on being tried or punished twice for the same offence (ne bis in idem) stops criminal proceedings for tax evasion after a tax surcharge was imposed for the same false information [1]. It also had to decide whether it had jurisdiction at all, and whether national courts may be required to find a clear breach before they set aside national rules [1].
The outcome
The Court held that it had jurisdiction [1]. Article 50 of the Charter does not prevent a Member State from imposing a tax penalty and then a criminal penalty for the same VAT declaration failures, as long as the first penalty is not criminal in nature, which the national court determines [1]. EU law also precludes a practice that makes setting aside a national rule conditional on the breach being clear from the Charter's text or case-law [1]. The fifth question was declared inadmissible [1].
The Court’s reasoning
On jurisdiction, the Court recalled that the Charter binds Member States only when they implement EU law (Article 51(1)) [1]. It stated that the applicability of EU law entails the applicability of the Charter's fundamental rights [1]. Every Member State must take all measures needed to collect the VAT due and prevent evasion, under Directive 2006/112 and Article 4(3) TEU [1]. Article 325 TFEU also requires effective measures against fraud harming the EU's financial interests [1]. The Court saw a direct link between VAT collection and the EU budget [1]. Tax penalties and criminal proceedings for false VAT information therefore implement EU law, even if the national rules were not adopted to transpose the directive [1]. On the merits, Member States may choose administrative penalties, criminal penalties or a combination [1]. Article 50 applies only if the first penalty is criminal in nature and final [1]. Three criteria decide this: the national classification of the offence, the nature of the offence, and the severity of the penalty [1]. On the first question, the ECHR is not formally part of EU law, but a national court must give full effect to EU law and may refer questions to the Court of Justice [1]. The fifth question concerned legislation that does not exist in Swedish law, so it was hypothetical [1].
What the judgment means
This section is an assessment, not legal advice. On this reading, the judgment does two main things. First, it reads the Charter's reach broadly in VAT matters: penalties and prosecutions for false VAT information count as implementing EU law, even where the national rules were not made to transpose a directive [1]. On this reading, this means Charter rights such as Article 50 can be relied on in such cases [1]. Second, it limits Article 50: a tax penalty followed by a criminal penalty is caught only if the first penalty is criminal in nature and final [1]. On this reading, the judgment does not itself decide whether the Swedish tax surcharge meets that test. It leaves this to the national court, guided by three criteria [1]. The Court also said national courts may check the combination of penalties against national standards, provided the Charter's level of protection and the primacy, unity and effectiveness of EU law are not compromised [1]. On this reading, the judgment does not govern how the ECHR relates to national law [1]. It also gives no answer to the fifth question [1]. Later judgments repeat that the principle prohibits duplication of criminal proceedings and penalties [4][7].
How the sources fit together
Advocate General Cruz Villalón proposed that the Court lacked jurisdiction, because the link between the VAT directive and the national penalty system was in his view extremely weak [2]. The Court did not follow him and found that the case implemented EU law [1]. The case turned on Articles 50 and 51(1) of the Charter, Article 325 TFEU, Directive 2006/112 and Article 4 of Protocol No 7 to the ECHR [1]. Later judgments rely on it. One repeats that VAT penalties and prosecutions implement EU law [3]. Others cite it for the three criteria on whether penalties are criminal [7], for the ban on duplicating criminal proceedings and penalties [4], and for the point that the ECHR is not formally part of EU law [5]. Another repeats the Article 325 TFEU and EU budget reasoning [6]. An Advocate General later noted that the judgment caused difficulties for some national courts [8].
From the sources
The applicability of European Union law entails applicability of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Charter. [1]
These penalties may therefore take the form of administrative penalties, criminal penalties or a combination of the two. [1]
Therefore, the ne bis in idem principle prohibits a duplication both of proceedings and of penalties which are criminal in nature for the purposes of that article in respect of the same acts and against the same person [7]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-617/10: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber), 26 February 2013. — Åklagaren v Hans Åkerberg Fransson. the judgment · 26 February 2013
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-617/10: Opinion of Advocate General Cruz Villalón delivered on 12 June 2012. — Åklagaren v Hans Åkerberg Fransson. the Advocate General's opinion · 12 June 2012
- Judgment in Case C-217/15: Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 5 April 2017. — Criminal proceedings against Massimo Orsi and Luciano Baldetti. a later judgment that cites this case · 5 April 2017
- Judgment in Case C-524/15: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 20 March 2018. — Criminal proceedings against Luca Menci. a later judgment that cites this case · 20 March 2018
- Judgment in Case C-218/15: Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 6 October 2016. — Gianpaolo Paoletti and Others v Procura della Repubblica. a later judgment that cites this case · 6 October 2016
- Judgment in Case C-105/14: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 September 2015. — Criminal proceedings against Ivo Taricco and Others. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 September 2015
- Judgment in Case C-537/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 20 March 2018. — Garlsson Real Estate SA and Others v Commissione Nazionale per le Società e la Borsa (Consob). a later judgment that cites this case · 20 March 2018
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-524/15: Opinion of Advocate General Campos Sánchez-Bordona delivered on 12 September 2017. — Criminal proceedings against Luca Menci. another EU document with similar content · 12 September 2017