When a Member State breaks EU law through its parliament, individuals may claim damages
The Brasserie du Pêcheur judgment asked whether a Member State must pay damages for breaches of Community law by its legislature. The Court said yes, if the rule breached confers rights, the breach is sufficiently serious and it directly caused the loss.
The case
Brasserie du Pêcheur, a French brewery, said it stopped exporting beer to Germany in late 1981. German authorities considered its beer did not meet the German purity rules in the beer duty law [1]. The Court had already ruled in 1987 that the German ban on importing such beers breached Article 30 of the EEC Treaty [1]. The brewery then sued Germany for about DM 1.8 million, a fraction of its loss between 1981 and 1987 [1]. In the second case, Factortame Ltd and others challenged the UK Merchant Shipping Act 1988, which set nationality, residence and domicile conditions for registering fishing vessels. The Court held those conditions contrary to Community law [1]. The claimants sought compensation for losses incurred while the rules applied [1]. The national courts asked whether Community law gives them a right to damages from the state [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether a Member State must make good damage caused to individuals by breaches of Community law, including breaches by the national legislature [1]. It also had to set the conditions for that liability, the role of fault and the extent of compensation [1].
The outcome
The Court held that the principle of State liability applies where the national legislature caused the breach [1]. Individuals are entitled to reparation where the rule breached is meant to confer rights on them, the breach is sufficiently serious and a direct causal link exists [1]. Compensation cannot depend on fault going beyond a sufficiently serious breach, and loss of profit cannot be excluded in general [1]. The Court left the facts and the final outcome of both cases to the national courts [1].
The Court’s reasoning
The Court said that the right to rely directly on Treaty provisions in national courts is only a minimum guarantee and does not ensure full implementation of Community law [1]. Where a directly effective right is breached, the right to reparation is the necessary corollary of that direct effect [1]. The principle is inherent in the Treaty system and applies whichever organ of the state caused the breach [1]. Because Community law must be applied uniformly, domestic rules on the division of powers cannot block liability [1]. To set the conditions, the Court drew on the full effectiveness of Community rules, the effective protection of rights, the duty of cooperation in Article 5, and the Community liability rules in Article 215 [1]. Where the legislature has a wide discretion, the test is whether the state manifestly and gravely disregarded the limits of that discretion [1]. A breach that continues after a judgment finding it unlawful is sufficiently serious [1]. Damages must be commensurate with the loss, and national law cannot exclude loss of profit in general [1]. Reparation cannot be limited to damage arising after a Court judgment finding the breach [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment's main contribution is to state that a Member State can be liable to individuals for breaches of Community law by its legislature, and to set out three conditions for that liability [1]. This is an assessment, not legal advice. On this reading, the Court treats the decisive test as whether the Member State manifestly and gravely disregarded the limits on its discretion [1]. To apply that test, it lists factors that the national court may take into consideration, such as the clarity of the rule breached, whether the breach was intentional, and whether any error of law was excusable [1]. On this reading, the judgment leaves the assessment of the facts and of how serious a breach was to national courts, which decide those questions [1]. On this reading, it also leaves the criteria for calculating damages to national law, subject to the rules that they must not be less favourable and must not make reparation practically impossible [1]. Later judgments repeat the principle, for example by describing it as settled case-law [3]. On this reading, these later references show how the principle has been used, but they do not show how any particular claim would be decided [3][4].
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General's opinion covers the same questions [2]. The excerpt available to us stops before his final conclusions, so we cannot say what he proposed on each point [2]. Articles 30 and 52 were the provisions infringed in the two cases, and they were used to show the first condition, that the rule confers rights on individuals [1]. The reasoning on State liability itself rests on the full effectiveness of Community rules, the effective protection of rights, the duty of cooperation in Article 5, and the Court's task under Article 164 [1]. It also draws on the Court's case-law on Community liability under Article 215 and builds on the Francovich judgment [1]. Later judgments cite this case for the principle that liability exists for breaches of EU law by any public authority [3]. Another judgment restates the three conditions: a rule intended to confer rights, a sufficiently serious breach and a direct causal link [4].
From the sources
the principle that Member States are obliged to make good damage caused to individuals by breaches of Community law attributable to the State is applicable where the national legislature was responsible for the breach in question [1]
the right of individuals to rely on the directly effective provisions of the Treaty before national courts is only a minimum guarantee [1]
the breach is sufficiently serious and there is a direct causal link between the breach and the damage sustained by the individuals [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-46/93: Judgment of the Court of 5 March 1996. — Brasserie du Pêcheur SA v Bundesrepublik Deutschland and The Queen v Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte: Factortame Ltd and o the judgment · 5 March 1996
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-46/93: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Tesauro delivered on 28 November 1995. — Brasserie du Pêcheur SA v Bundesrepublik Deutschland and The Queen v Secretary the Advocate General's opinion · 28 November 1995
- Judgment in Case C-168/15: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 28 July 2016. — Milena Tomášová v Slovenská republika - Ministerstvo spravodlivosti SR and Pohotovosť s.r.o. a later judgment that cites this case · 28 July 2016
- Judgment in Case C-98/14: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 11 June 2015. — Berlington Hungary Tanácsadó és Szolgáltató kft and Others v Magyar Állam. a later judgment that cites this case · 11 June 2015