Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Simmenthal: national courts must set aside conflicting national law

Court of JusticeInstitutions and the rule of lawJudgment in Case C-106/779 March 1978

In Simmenthal, an Italian court asked whether it must wait for the Constitutional Court before ignoring a later national law that conflicts with EU (Community) law. The Court said no: the national court must set the conflicting law aside itself.

Read the full judgment

Auf Deutsch


The case

Simmenthal SpA, a company based in Monza, was in a dispute with the Italian Finance Administration. The dispute concerned veterinary and public health fees charged on imports of beef and veal. The fee scale was last set by Law No 1239 of 30 December 1970. [1] After an earlier ruling of the Court of Justice, the Pretore di Susa found the fees incompatible with Community law. He ordered repayment with interest. The Finance Administration appealed. [1] The Pretore then saw a conflict between Community rules and a later national law. Under recent decisions of the Italian Constitutional Court, he would have had to refer the question to that court. It could declare the law unconstitutional. [1] He asked the Court of Justice two questions on 28 July 1977. [1] During the case, the Italian Government said the Constitutional Court had since declared some provisions of the 1970 law unconstitutional. It argued that the questions no longer mattered. [1]

The question

The Court had to decide whether a national court, faced with a directly applicable Community rule and a conflicting later national law, must disregard that law at once. The alternative was to wait until the law is repealed or declared unconstitutional. The second question asked whether such a repeal must always have fully retroactive effect. [1]

The outcome

The Court ruled that a national court applying Community law must give it full effect. If necessary, it must refuse on its own motion to apply a conflicting national provision, even a later one. It does not have to request or await the prior removal of that provision by legislative or other constitutional means. [1] The Court found that the second question had no purpose. It also rejected the Italian Government's objection that the questions were moot. [1] The Court did not decide the fee dispute itself. The decision on costs was left to the Pretore di Susa. [1]

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first dealt with the objection that the questions were moot. It treats a reference as validly before it until the referring court withdraws it or a higher court quashes it. The Constitutional Court's judgment came from unconnected proceedings and could not change that. [1] On the substance, the Court said directly applicable rules must apply fully and uniformly in all Member States from their entry into force. They are a direct source of rights and duties for States and individuals. [1] National courts must protect those rights. [1] Because Community law takes precedence, such rules make any conflicting current national law automatically inapplicable. They also prevent the valid adoption of new national laws that would be incompatible with them. [1] Treating such national measures as legally effective would deny the effectiveness of the obligations Member States took on under the Treaty. It would imperil the foundations of the Community. [1] The Court also pointed to Article 177, which lets any national court make a reference. That provision would be weakened if the court could not apply Community law at once. [1] A national practice that reserves the solution of the conflict to another authority is incompatible with Community law, even if the delay is only temporary. [1] The second question followed from the answer to the first. [1]

What the judgment means

This section is an assessment, not legal advice. On this reading, the judgment establishes that the national judge hearing a case is itself responsible for giving Community law full effect. The judge may not hand that task to another body and wait. [1] The duty covers conflicting national law adopted before or after the Community rule. [1] On this reading, the ruling is tied to cases where a court applies Community law within its own jurisdiction. The Court spoke of provisions that are directly applicable. [1] The judgment does not decide the fee dispute in the main action. It does not say how national procedures must otherwise be organised. The Advocate General noted that Community law is not concerned with removing national procedures for declaring laws unconstitutional. What matters is that those procedures do not block the application of Community law. [2] Later judgments suggest the principle has been widely reused. One repeats the formulation almost word for word. [3] Another says a national court must disapply conflicting national provisions on its own initiative. [5] Others cite the case for the duty of national courts to ensure that Community law takes full effect. [4][6] One cites it as explaining the precedence of Community law. [7] We would not read the sources as going beyond this. They do not show how the principle works in every possible situation.

How the sources fit together

Advocate General Reischl reached the same answer. In his view, conflicting later national provisions may no longer be applied to directly applicable Community rules. This applies at once, without waiting for repeal or a declaration of unconstitutionality. [2] The Court followed this result. [1][2] Both also kept the questions before the Court despite the Italian Government's objection. [1][2] The Court relied on Article 189 of the Treaty on direct applicability and on Article 177 on references. [1] It also referred to Article 11 of the Italian Constitution, which was the basis of the Italian Constitutional Court's approach. [1] Later judgments cite the case in different ways. Two repeat its operative rule. [3][5] Two cite paragraph 16 on the duty of national courts to ensure that Community law takes full effect. [4][6] One cites it as explaining the precedence of Community law. [7]

From the sources

A national court which is called upon, within the limits of its jurisdiction, to apply provisions of community law is under a duty to give full effect to those provisions [1]
Must accordingly set aside any provision of national law which may conflict with it, whether prior or subsequent to the community rule [1]
where provisions of national law are incompatible with Community law, the national court is under a duty to give full effect to Community law by disapplying on its own initiative conflicting provisions of national law [5]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-106/77: Judgment of the Court of 9 March 1978. — Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato v Simmenthal SpA. the judgment · 9 March 1978
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-106/77: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Reischl delivered on 16 February 1978. — Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato v Simmenthal SpA. the Advocate General's opinion · 16 February 1978
  3. Judgment in Case C-170/88: Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 11 July 1989. — Ford España SA v Estado español. a later judgment that cites this case · 11 July 1989
  4. Judgment in Case C-379/04: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 13 October 2005. — Richard Dahms GmbH v Fränkischer Weinbauverband eV. a later judgment that cites this case · 13 October 2005
  5. Judgment in Case C-358/95: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 13 March 1997. — Tommaso Morellato v Unità sanitaria locale (USL) n. 11 di Pordenone. a later judgment that cites this case · 13 March 1997
  6. Judgment in Case C-253/00: Judgment of the Court of 17 September 2002. — Antonio Muñoz y Cia SA and Superior Fruiticola SA v Frumar Ltd and Redbridge Produce Marketing Ltd. a later judgment that cites this case · 17 September 2002
  7. Judgment in Case C-249/85: Judgment of the Court of 21 May 1987. — Albako Margarinefabrik Maria von der Linde GmbH & Co. KG v Bundesanstalt für landwirtschaftliche Marktordnung. a later judgment that cites this case · 21 May 1987