Les Verts: Parliament's election funding scheme can be challenged in court
In Les Verts, the Court asked whether the Parliament's decisions on funding for the 1984 election campaign can be challenged in court. It held that they can, and annulled them because the scheme invaded powers kept by the Member States.
The case
The European Parliament's budget contained an item, Item 3708, to pay for an information campaign before the 1984 European elections. In total 43 million ECU was set aside.[1] In October 1982 the Parliament's Bureau decided how to share the money. Each political group received a flat 1% and a sum per member. A further 31% went to a reserve for all groupings that won enough votes in 1984.[1] In October 1983 the enlarged Bureau adopted rules on how the reserve would be shared. These rules also set out how groupings without seats could claim reimbursement.[1] The French ecologist association Les Verts – Parti écologiste had no representatives in the Parliament. It asked the Court to annul both measures.[1] During the case it merged into a new association. The new association put up a list in the 1984 elections and received 82 958 ECU from the Parliament.[1]
The question
Can the Court review a measure adopted by the European Parliament, and can a political grouping without seats challenge it? If so, was the Parliament's funding scheme lawful?[1]
The outcome
The Court held the action admissible. It declared void the Bureau's decision of 12 October 1982 and the rules of 29 October 1983.[1] It found that the scheme was in substance a reimbursement of election campaign expenses. Under the 1976 Act on direct elections, the Member States kept the power to regulate that.[1] Each party bore its own costs, because the applicant had not asked for costs.[1]
The Court’s reasoning
The Court first accepted that the new association could continue the case. The old associations were dissolved and merged by a single act, so there was legal and temporal continuity between them.[1] The Court then checked admissibility of its own motion.[1] Article 173 of the Treaty names only the Council and the Commission. The Court said the Community is based on the rule of law, and the Treaty set up a complete system of remedies to review the institutions' measures.[1] The general scheme is a direct action against all measures intended to have legal effects. Excluding the Parliament would be contrary to the spirit of Article 164 and to the system. The Parliament could then encroach on the powers of the Member States or other institutions without any review.[1] The contested measures shared money among third parties, so they had legal effects.[1] They were of direct concern to the applicant because the calculation was automatic.[1] The applicant was also individually concerned. Otherwise groupings without seats would get less protection, because they could not challenge the scheme before the elections.[1] On the merits, the scheme could not be distinguished from flat-rate reimbursement of campaign expenses. Information and party propaganda were inseparable, and the funds could be spent during the campaign.[1] The electoral procedure in Article 7(2) of the 1976 Act covers such rules, and the Act does not cover reimbursement. That power therefore stayed with the Member States.[1]
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment shows that the Court did not read Article 173 only by its wording. It looked at the Treaty's general scheme and the need for review of measures with legal effects.[1] The Court stated that an action for annulment may lie against Parliament measures intended to have legal effects vis-a-vis third parties.[1] On this reading, the reasoning rests on the rule of law and on the lack of any other review route for such measures.[1] The reach of the judgment seems limited by its wording, which speaks of measures intended to have legal effects on third parties.[1] The Court also described the situation as one that had never before come before it.[1] It did not rule on the other submissions, such as equal treatment and the competition rules, because the breach of the 1976 Act was enough.[1] Nor did it decide whether the Parliament may itself bring actions against other institutions. The Parliament had argued that point, but the Court did not address it.[1] The judgment also leaves open how an information campaign could be funded if it were clearly different from reimbursement of campaign costs.[1]
How the sources fit together
Advocate General Mancini favoured the interpretation giving the greatest protection. He argued that Article 173 should be read to cover Parliament acts.[2] The Court followed him on that point.[1][2] On individual concern, he concluded that the condition was not met, but the Court found that it was.[1][2] Later judgments rely on the case. In a later case between the same parties, the Court recorded that it had annulled the Bureau's decision and the 1983 rules.[3] One later judgment repeats the rule of law passage.[4] Another cites paragraph 19 for the point that the Court may examine admissibility of its own motion.[5] Another quotes the passage on a complete system of remedies. It then reasons that Article 173 gives the Court exclusive jurisdiction to declare an act of an institution void.[6]
From the sources
An action for annulment may lie against measures adopted by the european parliament intended to have legal effects vis-a-vis third parties [1]
The financing scheme set up cannot be distinguished from a scheme providing for flat-rate reimbursement of election campaign expenses [1]
neither its Member States nor its institutions can avoid a review of the question whether the measures adopted by them are in conformity with the basic constitutional charter, the Treaty [4]
The admissibility of an action is an issue of public policy which may be raised by the Court of its own motion [5]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-294/83: Judgment of the Court of 23 April 1986. — Parti écologiste "Les Verts" v European Parliament. the judgment · 23 April 1986
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-294/83: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Mancini delivered on 4 December 1985. — Parti écologiste "Les Verts" v European Parliament. the Advocate General's opinion · 4 December 1985
- Judgment in Case C-190/84: Judgment of the Court of 25 February 1988. — Parti écologiste "Les Verts" v European Parliament. a later judgment that cites this case · 25 February 1988
- Judgment in Case C-314/91: Judgment of the Court of 23 March 1993. — Beate Weber v European Parliament. a later judgment that cites this case · 23 March 1993
- Judgment in Case T-85/07: Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber) of 10 June 2008. — Gabel Industria Tessile SpA v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Des a later judgment that cites this case · 10 June 2008
- Judgment in Case C-314/85: Judgment of the Court of 22 October 1987. — Foto-Frost v Hauptzollamt Lübeck-Ost. a later judgment that cites this case · 22 October 1987