Kadi: EU courts can review UN-based asset freezes for human rights
In Kadi, the Court asked whether EU courts can review an EU asset-freezing regulation that implements UN sanctions. It said yes and annulled the freeze for the two appellants, but kept it in force for up to three months.
The case
Two appellants were named on a list drawn up by the UN Security Council's Sanctions Committee: a person living in Saudi Arabia and Al Barakaat International Foundation, based in Sweden [1]. The Security Council had ordered States to freeze the funds of people and entities linked to Usama bin Laden, the Al-Qaeda network and the Taliban [1]. On 27 May 2002 the Council of the European Union adopted Regulation No 881/2002 to apply this in the Community, relying on Articles 60 EC, 301 EC and 308 EC as its legal basis [1]. Annex I to the regulation listed both appellants, so their funds were frozen [1]. The Council never told them what evidence was used against them [1]. They asked the Court of First Instance to annul the regulation. It rejected their actions on 21 September 2005, holding that it could check the UN resolutions only against the highest rules of international law, called jus cogens [1]. They appealed to the Court of Justice [1].
The question
Did the Community have a legal basis to adopt the regulation? And can the Community courts review such a regulation against fundamental rights, even though it gives effect to binding UN Security Council resolutions [1]?
The outcome
The Court of Justice set aside the Court of First Instance's judgments [1]. It held that Articles 60 EC, 301 EC and 308 EC together were a valid legal basis [1]. It nonetheless annulled the regulation so far as it concerned the appellants, because their rights of defence, their right to effective judicial protection and, for the individual appellant, the right to property had been breached [1]. The effects of the regulation were kept for up to three months [1].
The Court’s reasoning
On the legal basis, the Court found that Articles 60 EC and 301 EC cover measures against third countries. The UN measures at issue had no link to the governing regime of a third country, so those articles alone were not enough [1]. Article 308 EC could fill that gap. The Court saw an implicit Community objective in those articles: adopting such economic measures through an efficient Community instrument. It also saw a link to the common market, because separate national freezes could distort it [1]. The Court rejected the Court of First Instance's 'bridge' reasoning, but found its conclusion justified on other grounds [1]. On fundamental rights, the Court stressed that the Community is based on the rule of law and that an international agreement cannot affect the autonomy of its legal system [1]. Review would apply to the Community regulation, not to the UN resolution itself [1]. Article 307 EC cannot permit any challenge to the Community's founding principles [1]. The UN re-examination procedure was diplomatic and offered no judicial protection [1]. The Council had not communicated the evidence to the appellants, so their right to be heard and to effective judicial protection were not respected [1]. The freeze was also an unjustified restriction of the property right, because the individual appellant had no chance to put his case [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the judgment sets out a clear principle: Community acts must respect fundamental rights, and the Court reviews them in full, even when they implement UN Security Council resolutions [1]. The Court did not review the UN resolution itself [1]. It also did not decide that the freezes were unjustified on the merits. It said the measures might still prove justified and kept the regulation's effects for a short period [1]. It accepted that a person need not be heard or told the grounds before a first listing, because surprise matters, but the grounds must be communicated as swiftly as possible afterwards [1]. The later judgments among the sources repeat specific passages of Kadi. Several General Court judgments cite paragraph 336 for the idea that review of restrictive measures must cover the lawfulness of the grounds for listing [5][6][7]. One of them applies this to Iran-related asset freezes, citing the individual nature of the measures and their impact on rights [7]. Another judgment cites paragraph 285 for the point that international agreements must be fully compatible with the Treaties and their constitutional principles [4]. On this reading, these sources show only these uses of Kadi. They do not show how far the principle reaches in other fields [4][5][6][7].
How the sources fit together
Advocate General Poiares Maduro disagreed with the Court on the legal basis. He thought Articles 60 EC and 301 EC alone were enough and that Article 308 EC could not serve as a bridge [2]. The Court held that Article 308 EC could be included alongside those articles [1]. On jurisdiction, he found that the Court of First Instance erred in refusing to review the regulation against fundamental rights, and the Court agreed [2][1]. Later judgments rely on the case. One says that restrictive measures like these are not criminal in character, but that the persons' procedural rights must still be respected, citing paragraphs 367 to 370 [3]. Others cite paragraph 336 on review of the grounds for a listing [5][6][7]. One cites paragraph 285 on compatibility with constitutional principles [4].
From the sources
the Community judicature must, in accordance with the powers conferred on it by the EC Treaty, ensure the review, in principle the full review, of the lawfulness of all Community acts [1]
the obligations imposed by an international agreement cannot have the effect of prejudicing the constitutional principles of the EC Treaty, which include the principle that all Community acts must respect fundamental rights [1]
cannot give rise to generalised immunity from jurisdiction within the internal legal order of the Community. [1]
restrictive measures such as those at issue in the present case are not of a criminal character [3]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-402/05: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 3 September 2008. — Yassin Abdullah Kadi and Al Barakaat International Foundation v Council of the European Union and Commission of the judgment · 3 September 2008
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-402/05: Opinion of Mr Advocate General Poiares Maduro delivered on 16 January 2008. — Yassin Abdullah Kadi and Al Barakaat International Foundation v Council the Advocate General's opinion · 16 January 2008
- Judgment in Case T-248/13: Judgment of the General Court (Third Chamber) of 13 December 2016 (Extracts). — Mohammed Al-Ghabra v European Commission. a later judgment that cites this case · 13 December 2016
- Judgment in Case C-266/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 27 February 2018. — Western Sahara Campaign UK v Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs and Secretary of State for Envi a later judgment that cites this case · 27 February 2018
- Judgment in Case T-433/15: Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber) of 5 June 2019. — Bank Saderat plc v Council of the European Union. a later judgment that cites this case · 5 June 2019
- Judgment in Case T-37/17: Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber) of 16 May 2019. — Bank Tejarat v Council of the European Union. a later judgment that cites this case · 16 May 2019
- Judgment in Case T-434/15: Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber) of 8 May 2019. — Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines and Others v Council of the European Union. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 May 2019