Internationale Handelsgesellschaft: EU rules are not invalid under national constitutions
In Internationale Handelsgesellschaft, the question was whether an EU cereal licence deposit breached German constitutional rights. The Court held that EU measures are judged only under EU law, and found no factor affecting their validity.
The case
The case came from the Verwaltungsgericht Frankfurt am Main, a German court. EU rules on cereal trade required anyone applying for an import or export licence to lodge a deposit, which is a sum of money guaranteeing that the trade will be carried out. If the transaction did not take place within the licence period, the deposit was forfeited, unless force majeure, meaning circumstances beyond the trader's control, applied [1]. The German court had until then refused to accept the validity of these provisions and wanted to end the legal uncertainty [1]. It held that the system breached German constitutional principles, including freedom of action, economic liberty and proportionality, and that EU law had to yield to them. It had already held the provisions invalid under the Basic Law [1][2]. The company Internationale Handelsgesellschaft argued that the deposit burden was excessive for trade [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether the deposit system in Regulation 120/67 and the forfeiture rule in Regulation 473/67, which released the deposit only in force majeure cases, were invalid. The German court's objection was that they conflicted with German constitutional rights [1].
The outcome
The Court found that examination of the questions revealed no factor capable of affecting the validity of the two provisions [1]. The Court answered only the question of validity; the dispute in the main proceedings is for the national court to decide [1].
The Court’s reasoning
The Court held that the validity of EU measures can only be judged in the light of EU law. It stated that EU law, as an independent source of law, cannot be overridden by national rules, however framed, without losing its character as EU law [1]. Respect for fundamental rights forms part of the general principles of law that the Court protects. These rights must be ensured within the framework of the structure and objectives of the Community [1]. The Court found that requiring licences with a deposit was both necessary and appropriate, under Articles 40(3) and 43 of the EEC Treaty, to let the authorities manage market interventions effectively [1]. It also held that the burden of the deposit was not excessive compared with the value of the goods and other trading costs. Forfeiture was not a penalty but a guarantee that a voluntarily assumed undertaking would be carried out [1]. On force majeure, the Court held that the concept is not limited to absolute impossibility. It covers unusual circumstances outside the trader's control whose consequences could not have been avoided, even with due care, except at the cost of excessive sacrifice [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the central point of the judgment is that EU measures can be tested only against EU law, not against the constitution of a Member State [1]. Fundamental rights are part of the general principles the Court protects, but they must be ensured within the structure and objectives of the Community [1]. On this reading, this means that a claim that an EU measure conflicts with national constitutional rights cannot by itself affect its validity or effect in that state [4]. The judgment also shows that a deposit linked to a licence can be treated as a guarantee rather than a penalty [1]. The judgment does not decide the wider question of whether EU institutions may impose penalties in general, which the Advocate General said did not need to be settled [2]. It also does not decide other cases or other regulations, and it is not advice on any particular licence. Later judgments have relied on the same principle, but only as far as the sources show [4][6].
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General's opinion rejected the German court's argument that national constitutional rights could decide the validity of EU rules [2]. It indicated that the system should be upheld, and the Court's answer on validity points the same way [1][2]. The judgment turned on Article 12(1) of Regulation 120/67 on the deposit and Article 9 of Regulation 473/67 on force majeure [1]. A later ruling on the same deposit system described the question as materially identical to this one [3]. Later judgments cite the case for the rule that national constitutional claims cannot affect validity [4][6], and for the concept of force majeure [5][7].
From the sources
The law stemming from the treaty, an independent source of law, cannot because of its very nature be overridden by rules of national law, however framed [1]
The system of deposits violates no fundamental right [1]
The concept of force majeure is not limited to absolute impossibility but must be understood in the sense of unusual circumstances, outside the control of the importer or exporter [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-11/70: Judgment of the Court of 17 December 1970. — Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH v Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel. the judgment · 17 December 1970
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-11/70: Joined opinion of Mr Advocate General Dutheillet de Lamothe delivered on 2 December 1970. — Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH v Einfuhr- und Vorra the Advocate General's opinion · 2 December 1970
- Judgment in Case C-38/70: Judgment of the Court of 10 March 1971. — Deutsche Tradax GmbH v Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel. a later judgment that cites this case · 10 March 1971
- Judgment in Case C-234/85: Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 8 October 1986. — Staatsanwaltschaft Freiburg v Franz Keller. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 October 1986
- Judgment in Case C-124/92: Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 13 October 1993. — An Bord Bainne Co-operative Ltd and Compagnie Interagra SA v Intervention Board for Agricultural Produce. a later judgment that cites this case · 13 October 1993
- Judgment in Case C-249/85: Judgment of the Court of 21 May 1987. — Albako Margarinefabrik Maria von der Linde GmbH & Co. KG v Bundesanstalt für landwirtschaftliche Marktordnung. a later judgment that cites this case · 21 May 1987
- Judgment in Case C-208/01: Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 17 October 2002. — Isabel Parras Medina and Adelina Parras Medina v Consejería de Agricultura y Medio Ambiente de la Junta de Comuni a later judgment that cites this case · 17 October 2002