Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

EU Commission must explain why it cannot find requested text messages

General CourtInstitutions and the rule of lawJudgment in Case T-36/2314 May 2025

The question was whether the Commission had to explain why it held no requested text messages between its President and a pharmaceutical CEO. The Court annulled the refusal because the Commission gave no plausible explanation.

Read the full judgment

En français


The case

A journalist working for The New York Times asked the European Commission in May 2022 for all text messages between the President of the Commission and the chief executive officer of Pfizer from 1 January 2021 to 11 May 2022 [1]. The Commission did not reply within the time limit, then said it held no documents matching the request [1]. After a confirmatory application, the Commission confirmed in a decision of 15 November 2022 that it did not hold any such documents, despite a renewed and thorough search [1]. The applicants, the journalist and The New York Times Company, brought an action for annulment before the General Court [1]. They argued that press reports and interviews showed the messages existed, so the Commission had to explain why they could not be found [1]. The Commission argued that the messages were short-lived and unimportant, so they were not registered [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether the Commission breached the principle of good administration by refusing access on the ground that it held no documents, after the applicants had cast doubt on that claim [1]. In particular, it had to decide whether the Commission had to give plausible explanations for why the requested documents could not be found [1].

The outcome

The Court annulled the Commission's decision and ordered the Commission to pay the costs [1]. The applicants won on their third plea, which alleged a breach of good administration, so the Court did not need to rule on the other pleas [1]. The Commission lost the case in full [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court first held that the action was admissible because one applicant, Ms Stevi, had standing, so it did not need to examine the standing of the company [1]. It accepted late-filed interview transcripts because the delay was justified [1]. On the merits, the Court explained that a refusal can be challenged even when the institution says a document does not exist, and that the institution must justify its refusal [1]. A presumption of veracity applies to a statement that a document does not exist, but it can be rebutted by relevant and consistent evidence [1]. Here, a press article, interviews and a report of the European Court of Auditors made the existence of exchanges plausible, so the presumption was rebutted [1]. The Commission then had to give plausible explanations. It did not specify its search methods or storage locations, did not say whether the President's phones were checked, and could not say whether the messages were deleted or whether phones were replaced [1]. Relying only on the absence of registration was not enough [1]. The Court also stressed that institutions must draw up and retain documentation in a non-arbitrary and predictable manner [1]. Because the Commission's explanations rested on assumptions, it breached the principle of good administration in Article 41 of the Charter [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment means that an EU institution cannot end an access request simply by stating that a document does not exist [1]. Where there is relevant and consistent evidence that a document once existed, the institution must give a clear account of how it searched and what became of the document [1]. The ruling also indicates that non-registration of a document is not, on its own, a sufficient explanation [1]. Its reach is tied to these facts: the messages concerned contacts linked to COVID-19 vaccine procurement, and the evidence that rebutted the presumption was specific to them [1]. The judgment does not decide whether the messages should have been registered or retained under the Commission's rules, and it does not order disclosure of any documents [1]. It also does not set out how detailed every search must be [1]. This is an assessment only, not legal advice, and it should not be used to predict how other access cases will be decided [1].

How the sources fit together

Source 1 is the judgment of the General Court (Grand Chamber) and is the main text for this summary [1]. Source 2 is headed as the Advocate General's opinion, but its text matches the judgment and contains no separate opinion, so it does not show what the Advocate General proposed [2]. The judgment turns on the presumption of veracity, the duty to give plausible explanations and the principle of good administration in Article 41 of the Charter, all of which it sets out itself [1].

From the sources

the Commission cannot rely solely on the absence of registration in its system for managing the requested documents to establish that it did not hold those documents, without any other explanation [1]
the Commission did not provide in the contested decision any plausible explanation as to why it had not been able to find the requested documents [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case T-36/23: Judgment of the General Court (Grand Chamber) of 14 May 2025. — Matina Stevi and The New York Times Company v European Commission. the judgment · 14 May 2025
  2. Judgment in Case T-36/23: Judgment of the General Court (Grand Chamber) of 14 May 2025. — Matina Stevi and The New York Times Company v European Commission. the Advocate General's opinion · 14 May 2025