Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Achmea: EU law overrides arbitration clauses in investment treaties between EU states

Court of JusticeInstitutions and the rule of lawJudgment in Case C-284/166 March 2018

In Achmea, the question was whether an investment treaty clause letting an investor sue an EU Member State before an arbitral tribunal is compatible with EU law. The Court ruled that Articles 267 and 344 TFEU preclude such a clause.

Read the full judgment

Auf Deutsch


The case

The dispute involves Achmea, a company in a Netherlands insurance group, and the Slovak Republic. In 2004 Slovakia opened its private sickness insurance market to operators from other Member States. Achmea set up a subsidiary there and offered private sickness insurance [1]. In 2006 and 2007 Slovakia reversed part of this liberalisation, including a ban on distributing profits [1]. The Slovak Constitutional Court later held the ban unconstitutional, and a law from 1 August 2011 allowed profit distribution again [1]. In October 2008 Achmea started arbitration against Slovakia under Article 8 of a 1991 bilateral investment treaty with the Netherlands, with Frankfurt am Main as the seat [1]. Slovakia argued that EU accession made this arbitration route incompatible with EU law. The tribunal rejected that objection and in December 2012 awarded Achmea EUR 22.1 million [1]. Slovakia asked the German courts to set the award aside, and the Bundesgerichtshof referred questions to the Court [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether Articles 267 and 344 TFEU preclude a clause in an intra-EU investment treaty that lets an investor bring proceedings against a Member State before an arbitral tribunal [1]. The referring court also asked whether Article 18 TFEU on non-discrimination precludes such a clause [1].

The outcome

The Court ruled that Articles 267 and 344 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding such a provision, such as Article 8 of the BIT [1]. The arbitral tribunal cannot be a court of a Member State, so it cannot refer questions to the Court, and the clause adversely affects the autonomy of EU law [1]. Because it answered the first two questions, the Court did not rule on the third [1]. On the main point, the answer agrees with the Slovak Republic's doubts about the clause, which the referring court had not shared [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court started from the autonomy of the EU legal order. An international agreement cannot change the allocation of powers fixed by the Treaties, and Article 344 TFEU reflects this [1]. The preliminary ruling procedure in Article 267 TFEU is the keystone of the judicial system that secures uniform interpretation of EU law [1]. The Court accepted that the arbitral tribunal may have to interpret or apply EU law, because EU law forms part of the law the tribunal applies under Article 8(6) of the BIT [1]. But the tribunal is not part of the judicial system of the Netherlands or Slovakia, and it is not a court common to several Member States like the Benelux Court [1]. So it cannot be regarded as a court or tribunal of a Member State and cannot refer questions [1]. Review of the award by German courts is limited [1]. In commercial arbitration, the Court has accepted limited review because efficient arbitration justifies it, provided fundamental EU provisions can be examined and referred to the Court [1]. That case law does not carry over to BIT arbitration. Commercial arbitration rests on the parties' freely expressed wishes, while BIT arbitration derives from a treaty by which Member States remove disputes from their own courts [1]. The Court concluded that the mechanism could prevent disputes involving EU law from being resolved in a way that ensures its full effectiveness [1]. Article 8 calls into question mutual trust between Member States and the particular nature of EU law, so it is incompatible with sincere cooperation and adversely affects EU autonomy [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the principle from Achmea is that an investment treaty between Member States cannot give investors a route to an arbitral tribunal that bypasses the EU court system for applying EU law [1]. The operative answer is not limited to a treaty concluded before a State joined the EU. It covers any provision in an international agreement between Member States, such as Article 8 of the BIT, under which an investor may bring proceedings before an arbitral tribunal whose jurisdiction the State has accepted [1]. The referring question did concern a treaty concluded before accession, but the Court framed its answer more widely [1]. The reasons the Court gave, such as the tribunal's position outside the judicial system and the limited review, support its conclusion. They are not presented as a test that other tribunals must meet [1]. Later judgments have relied on the principle. The PL Holdings judgment quotes paragraphs 58 and 59 of Achmea, which state that such a clause is incompatible with the principle of sincere cooperation and has an adverse effect on the autonomy of EU law [3]. In that case, a party argued that the arbitration agreement predated the Achmea judgment [3]. The Komstroy judgment cited the finding that an ad hoc arbitral tribunal is not a component of a Member State's judicial system [4]. The judgment does not decide the question under Article 18 TFEU [1]. On this reading, it does not settle how the principle applies to every other type of arbitration [1].

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General's Opinion by Mr Wathelet is available here only in part, so the sources do not show his conclusion on the first two questions, and the Court's answer cannot be compared with it [2]. The Opinion states that the provisions of such a convention apply in so far as they are compatible with the EU and FEU Treaties [2], and notes that the Commission intervened in support of the Slovak Republic [2]. The Court's answer rests on Articles 267 and 344 TFEU [1]. Later judgments cite Achmea for its reasoning. The PL Holdings judgment relies on paragraphs 58 and 59 [3], and the Komstroy judgment cites paragraph 45 on the status of arbitral tribunals [4]. The Kokott Opinion in PL Holdings says Achmea found such arbitration clauses must be disapplied [5].

From the sources

precluding a provision in an international agreement concluded between Member States, such as Article 8 of the BIT [1]
a tribunal such as that referred to in Article 8 of the BIT cannot be regarded as a ‘court or tribunal of a Member State’ within the meaning of Article 267 TFEU [1]
Article 8 of the BIT is such as to call into question not only the principle of mutual trust between the Member States but also the preservation of the particular nature of the law established by the Treaties [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-284/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 6 March 2018. — Slowakische Republik v Achmea BV. the judgment · 6 March 2018
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-284/16: Opinion of Advocate General Wathelet delivered on 19 September 2017. — Slowakische Republik v Achmea BV. the Advocate General's opinion · 19 September 2017
  3. Judgment in Case C-109/20: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 26 October 2021. — Republiken Polen v PL Holdings Sàrl. a later judgment that cites this case · 26 October 2021
  4. Judgment in Case C-741/19: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 2 September 2021. — République de Moldavie v Komstroy LLC. a later judgment that cites this case · 2 September 2021
  5. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-109/20: Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 22 April 2021. — Republiken Polen v PL Holdings Sàrl. another EU document with similar content · 22 April 2021