Spring til indhold

Retsinformation

FORSVARSKOMMANDOBESTEMMELSE M.607-2 om grundlæggende principper for logistisk samarbejde mellem EUROGROUP lande.

BST nr 25020 af 31/01/1981BestemmelseForsvarsministeriet25. september 1997

Læs kilden ved Retsinformation (åbner i ny fane)

Teksten

FORSVARSKOMMANDOBESTEMMELSE M.607-2 om

grundlæggende principper for logistisk samarbejde mellem EUROGROUP lande.

Bilag: »EUROLOG Handbook of Basic Texts on Collaborative

Support«.

1. I overensstemmelse med EUROGROUP's deklaration om

logistisk samarbejde af 7 maj 1975 (bilag side 3) publiceres herved

"EUROLOG Handbook of Basic Texts on collaborative Support".

2. Ved udarbejdelse af bi- eller multilaterale

materielmæssige samarbejdsaftaler mellem danske og øvrige EUROGROUP nationers

myndigheder skal de i bilaget omhandlede principper og procedurer i videst

muligt omfang søges efterlevet.

EB

I.B.RODHOLM

kontreadmiral

chef for Materielstaben

CONTENTS

Fordeling: Standardfordeling.

BILAG: Page

Foreword 1

Declaration on Eurogroup Principles of Co-operation

in Logistics 3

Guidelines for Collaboration in Logistic Follow-on-

Support for Major Weapons/Equipment to be introduced

in Eurogroup Countries 7

Practical Procedures for Development of Collaborative

Follow-on Logistic Support for New Common Equipments 13

FOREWORD BY THE CHAIRMAN OF EUROLOG

EUROLOG (* 1) has been working for some years on devising arrangements to

ensure that opportunities for co-ordinated logistic support of collaborative

equipment projects are not prejudiced through decisions taken early in the

Læs alt

life of a project. Now that the three main documents involved are in final

form and have been agreed or endorsed as appropriate by Eurogroup Ministers,

it is timely to publish them together in this booklet, together with an

explanation of their usefulness, not only to logistic staffs, but also to

those working in the field of procurement who might be asked to respond to

requests for assistance from logisticians.

The management of international weapons projects is far from simple. The

factors underlying decisions increase in proportion to the number of

countries. Worse, countries may join or leave at different stages. The result

is that such weapons projects often have at their foundations a complex web

of agreements and understandings between countries, agencies, consortia and

firms. During this early and crucial stage it is unlikely that much thought

will have been given to the logistic support of the weapon - after all, the

procurement staffs are quite rightly giving all their attention to ensuring

that the Armed Forces receive the desired equipment at the right time.

The eventual equipment has, however, to be supported by logisticians for

perhaps twenty years and the cost of this in-service phase can be of the same

order as the initial outlay.

Unfortunately, it is often the case that the very practical and necessary

decisions reached by procurement authorities mean that it is difficult,

sometimes impossible, to set up rational, cooperative logistic support and

thereby reap the benfits - economy, standardisation, flexibility - that were

supposed to flow from the collaboration.

With this in mind EUROLOG formulated Principles of Co-operation in

Logistics which picked up a theme from EURONAD's Principles of Equipment

Collaboration that co-ordinated logistics should be automatically considered

as part of any collaborative project. In London on 7 May 1975 EUROGROUP

Ministers signed a Declaration (reproduced in this booklet) adopting the

Logistics Principles.

It remained to ensure that the Principles were translated into practice.

EUROLOG therefore drew up Guidelines which gave more specific direction as to

how co-operative logistic support of collaborative weapons should be pursued.

This document too was approved by EUROGROUP Ministers.

The task now fell on EUROLOG and its sub-groups to monitor the

implementation of the Principles and Guidelines. To give national logistics

staffs some guidance as to what logistics considerations should be taken into

account at the various stages of a project, a Procedure was drawn up, based

on the phases as defined in the NATO Periodic Armaments Planning System. This

Procedure should encourage uniformity of practice between the EUROGROUP

countries. It is not designed for literal application in every country,

because of differing administrative structures and practices but is intended

as a model which countries should strive to translate into their own context

through appropriate adjustments.

The successful application of these three documents rest on close liaison

between logistics and procurement staffs. In some countries this is

accomplished automatically through integration of the two functions. In

others there is a difficult gap to bridge. Recognizing the problem of those

logistics staffs who do not have automatic access to procurement staffs,

Ministers acknowledged (EG/27/80 (Final)) in 1980 »that national members

of EUROLOG Sub-Groups were exercising their monitoring responsibilities in

regard to arrangements for follow-on logistic support of collaborative

weapons projects on behalf of EUROGROUP Ministers and with authority derived

from them«.

I hope that this booklet, which brings into one volume the fruits of five

years work by EUROLOG, will be of assistance (and perhaps also an

inspiration) to procurement and logistics staff, national and international.

Air Vice Marshal J J Miller

Assistant Chief of the Defence Staff (Personnel and Logistics)

MOD United Kingdom

Chairman, EUROLOG

DECLARATION ON EUROGROUP PRINCIPLES OF CO-OPERATION IN LOGISTICS

The Ministers of Defence of Belgium, Denmark, the Federal Republic of

Germany, Greece, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Turkey and the

United Kingdom:

Desiring to achieve a greater measure of collaboration in logistic support

among European member states of the North Atlantic Alliance;

Anxious to make optimum use of their logistic resources;

on 7 May 1975 adopted the Principles of Co-operation in Logistics set out

in the Annex herewith as a basis for common action.

Ministers confirm their understanding that each will:

- Act in compliance with these principles;

- Disseminate them within his national Defence Ministry;

- Instruct all those of his staffs who have responsibility for logistics

to act in accordance with these principles.

PAUL VANDEN BOEYNANTS

Minister of National Defence

Belgium

EMILE KRIEPS

Minister of Defence

Luxembourg

ORLA MØLLER

Minister of Defence

Denmark

HENK VREDELING

Minister of Defence

The Netherlands

GEORG LEBER

Minister of Defence

Federal Republic of Germany

ALV JAKOB FOSTERVOLL

Minister of Defence

Norway

BYRON THEODOROPOULOS

Permanent Representative to NATO

acting for the

Minister of National Defence

Greece

FERIT MELEN

Minister of National Defence

Turkey

ARNALDO FORLANI

Minister of Defence

Italy

ROY MASON

Secretaty of State for Defence

United Kingdom

London 7 May 1975

ANNEX

EUROLOG PRINCIPLES OF CO-OPERATION IN LOGISTICS

I OBJECTIVES

1. One of the important overall objectives of the

Eurogroup is to increase co-operation in defence among member nations. The

field of logistics is one in which there is scope for improvements of this

kind. Although the provision of logistic support for NATO-assigned forces is

at present a national responsibility, closer collaboration in logistic

support will enable member countries whose forces are deployed in the same

area with similar or complementary operational responsibilities to make more

efficient and economical use of their logistic resources.

2. The ultimate objective is to achieve the closest

possible integration of logistics systems among Eurogroup members in respect

of the forces they assign to NATO. This is, however, dependent on fundamental

changes in the arrangements for financing those logistics systems and for the

procurement of equipment; and also on the achievement of much greater

standardization of weapons and equipment than exists at present. In the

meantime, worthwhile progress towards the objective can be made by developing

co- operative logistic arrangements and co-ordinated procedures wherever the

opportunity exists and greater efficiency and cost-effectiveness would

result.

II PRINCIPLES

3. The following principles have been drawn up to

provide a basis for co-operation in the field of logistic support:.

a. New Collaborative Projects for Weapons Systems and Major Equipments.

Practical possibilities of collaboration in support of weapons systems and

major equipments (egg, maintenance, repair and spares provisioning) are

limited by the differences between weapons and equipments at present used by

the member countries. A major effort is now being made by Eurogroup contries

through the work of EURONAD to promote standardization of new weapons and

equipment by means of collaborative projects. Member countries have already

agreed in the Principles of Equipment Collaboration that the requirement to

attempt to evolve co-ordinated arrangements for follow-on support be an

automatic accompaniment of any collaborative procurement project. EUROLOG

will work with the relevant agencies to satisfy themselves that appropriate

arrangements are being made in each case.

b. Other New Equipment Projects . Member countries agree that a similar

effort to evolve co-ordinated arrangements for follow-on support should be

made when any new weapon or equipment is under consideration or adopted by

two or more countries, whether or not the particular item is categorized as a

collaborative procurement project.

c. Existing Weapons or Equipments. Member countries agree that

consideration should be given to the possibility of co-operation in the

logistic support of existing weapons and equipments used by more than one

country which are not already the subject of co-operative arrangements.

d. Harmonization of Logistic Procedures. Member countries agree that every

effort will be made to harmonize/standardize logistic procedures with the

object of achieving increased flexibility in logistic support.

e. Future Logistic Planning. Member countries agree that they should

exchange information regularly about logistics, including information on

planned logistic projects, with the general aim of enabling others to join in

such projects if this would be of advantage. They agree also that there

should be a regular exchange of information on the evaluation of national

logistic concepts.

III METHOD OF IMPLEMENTATION

4. Responsibility for implementation of these

principles lies with Eurogroup countries, under the directiom of Eurogroup

Ministers. The sub-group established in the field of logistics (EUROLOG) has

so far devoted its main efforts to examining the possibilities of logistics

co-operation between the land forces in the Northern Army Group, between the

air forces in the Second Allied Tactical Air Force and between the navies

which operate in the Channel and the North Sea. The countries providing these

forces are at present represented on EUROLOG. It is open to other Eurogroup

countries to join EUROLOG when subjects of interest to them are under

consideration.

GUIDELINES POR COLLABORATION IN LOGISTIC FOLLOW-ON SUPPORT FOR MAJOR

WEAPONS/EQUIPMENT TO BE INTRODUCED IN EUROGROUP COUNTRIES

1. INTRODUCTION

The logistics required for the efficient and economical support of a new

weapon or major equipment, being introduced into the forces of two or more of

the EUROGROUP countries under collaborative or other arrangements, are

dependent upon such a wide range of factors that it is not possible to lay

down detailed procedures for universal application. Some guidelines for the

development of logistic support for such projects can be laid down, however,

providing it is accepted that the final arrangements are likely to vary in

each case. This memorandum has therefore been prepared by EUROLOG to provide

general guidance to nations considering the logistic support needed for

common weapon systems or major equipment to be used by two or more of the

EUROGROUP countries.

2. AIM

It is of the first importance to increase substantially the extent and

depth of the follow-on support of the defence equipment of the participating

countries. The aim of these guidelines is to ensure the adoption of a

consultative process among the EUROGROUP countries which lead to their

improved collaboration, with particular reference to the avoidance of

wasteful duplication among the participating countries in this area and the

realisation of both the economic and military benefits of enhanced

standardisation. The guidelines are in this respect an extension and

implementation of the approved »Principles of Co-operation in

Logistics«

3. GENERAL GUIDELINES

a. The prime object of the participating nations should be to establish

collaborative arrangements for the follow-on support of any collaborative or

other new weapon/equipment project, as already agreed by EUROGROUP nations in

paragraph 9 of the »Principles of Equipment Collaboration«. This

follow-on support should include, wherever possible, a most thorough

examination of all options for collaboration both in the procurement, holding

and distribution of spares and the provision of maintenance facilities (ie

servicing, repair and test facilities). A basic and substantial requirement

for any area of joint follow-on support is the commitment of all

participating countries to maintain wherever possible a uniform configuration

of the supported equipment.

b. The preparation of follow-on logistic arrangements should normally be

undertaken by logisticians of the participating nations, who should consult

other appropriate staff or agencies as necessary. Common NATO guidelines,

procedures and methods already in existence or being developed should be

taken into consideration.

c. NAMSA was set up by the NATO nations to provide logistic support

facilities for common weapons and equipment where this could be undertaken

more effectively and economically than could be achived individually by

participating nations. Thus consideration should always be given, as an

initial option, to the possibility of using the Agency for the logistic

support task. If the participating nations decide to offer a task to NAMSA

the normal procedure is to request NAMSO (through the Board of Directors) to

initiate a feasibility study prior to either the formation of a Weapons

System Partnership (WSP) or alternatively, the establishment of a programme.

The undermentioned guidelines would also apply in the case of a WSP

agreement.

4. EUROLOG INVESTIGATIONS

The investigation of major weapon systems and projects due to enter

service in the years ahead and the comprehensive joint examination of

national plans in these fields are essential to ensure that all worhtwhile

opportunities for collaboration are taken up. To this end EUROLOG will be

assembling lists of new weapon systems to be introduced in the Services of

the EUROGROUP countries. These lists will be kept under review periodically.

They will be updated by countries end examined jointly at least once a year.

5. GUIDELINES ON LOGISTICS ASPECTS

a. Co-ordination and Direction by participating Nations

(1) If appropriate a Joint Steering Committee, as a body of senior

representatives of the participating countries, should be established to

identify at an early stage in the life of a project possible areas for joint

logistic support and to co-ordinate logistics with eg training, procurement

or post-development.

(2) A Joint Working Group, composed of logistics experts and subordinate

to any Joint Steering Committee, should be set up to examine in detail the

possible areas, extent and types of logistic co-operation, to sponsor and

evaluate any feasibility studies and, subsequently, to implement the

agreement reached for logistics support.

b. Documentation. A formal document (ie Memorandum of Understanding or WSP

agreement) should be drawn up describing and defining the co-ordinated

logistic support arrangements mutually agreed by the participants.

c. Material Requirements. The main object of co-ordinating the material

requirements for follow-on logistic support is to achieve the cost benefits

which can normally be expected from larger purchases (ie economies of scale)

and limiting overall stocks to the minimum by pooling stockholdings wherever

possible. Among the factors to be considered are:

(1) Allocation of responsibility for the procurement of materials,

spares, etc (ie to a NATO Agency or to one of the participants);

(2) A facility to ensure that modification programmes are fully agreed

and co-ordinated by all participant nations so as to maintain a common

configuration and the ability to interchange main equipments, sub-assemblies

and modules between national weapon systems;

(3) Assessment of the range of materials, spares etc required to support

the weapon or major equipment concerned at user, maintenance and supply

levels;

(4) Naming, identification, classification and numbering in the NATO

Codification System of equipments, spares, tools and accessories to be held

at every level and/or by each participant;

(5) Identification of the size, location, funding and custodian of the

common pool of materials, spares, etc;

(6) The need for an agreed priority system for each participant's

requirements and arrangements for exceptional requirements (eg for combat

operational requirements and non-scaled items);

(7) Procedures for distribution of supplies, including timescales for

requisition and delivery, methods of handling, transportation and freight,

special cases for security and other special requirements;

(8) Planning of follow-on support arrangements and the method of

forecasting future requirements, including periodicity of replenishment

demands and identification of individual items;

(9) Identification of management and supply information needs and a

system for providing and updating them; (eg Data Collection Programme -

Evaluation of Unsatisfactory Equipment Reports (UER) - Evaluation of

Unsatisfactory Improvement Reports (UIR));

(10) Exchange of management and supply information and of engineering

information affecting supply;

(11) Disposal of excess or obsolete stocks;

(12) Accounting procedures;

(13) Required testing equipment, inspection facilities and tools;

(14) Drawing up of a calibration concept, including joint use of

facilities;

(15) Demands on preservation and packaging procedures including the

examination of the necessity and the scope of re-usable containers;

(16) Achieving a concept for the disposition and supervision of a

stockpile circuit for interchangeable articles;

(17) Determination of value standards (especially a definition of high

value items).

d. Maintenance, Overhaul and Repair. The main object is to establish

common or compatible maintenance policies so that engineering support

facilities can be fully utilised. Among the factors to be considered are;

(1) The definition of tasks to be undertaken and their division between

central (ie provided by a manufacturer, an agency or one of the participants)

and national resources;

(2) Provision of common technical publications, record of approved and/or

incorporated modifications, and other supporting documentation;

(3) Estimates of consumption of spares for individual maintenance,

overhaul and repair tasks;

(4) Provision of spare parts to support repair lines;

(5) Estimates of costs of maintenance, overhaul and repair;

(6) Training requirements in respect of maintenance, overhaul and repair;

(7) Provision of special tools and equipment;

(8) Exchange of information, including systems effectiveness, defects,

modifications and improvements.

e. Inter-changeability. In cases where a uniform configuration cannot be

obtained or maintained the participants should agree to the

interchangeability of assemblies and other component parts, wherever

practicable, so as to maximise cross servicing capabilities and minimise the

range of spares to be held centrally.

f. Quality Assurance. The participants should agree on the level and

extent of quality assurance to be adopted for:

(1) Equipment, spares, tools and accessories provided for the first fits

and for common and national stocks; and

(2) maintenance, overhaul and repair tasks.

g. Finance. Where support is carried out by NAMSA or another NATO agency

the normal arrangements for financing programmes undertaken by that Agency

will be followed. In other cases it will be necessary for the participating

countries to agree appropriate arrangements for cost sharing.

6. GENERAL

EUROLOG is responsible to the EUROGROUP Ministers for monitoring proposed

follow-on logistic arrangements for common weapon systems and major

equipments to ensure satisfactory arrangements are being made in each case.

These guidelines together with the Statement of Principles of Co-operation in

Logistics form a basis for such monitoring and consequent reports to

EUROGROUP.

PRACTICAL PROCEDURE FOR DEVELOPMENT OF COLLABORATIVE FOLLOW-ON LOGISTIC

SUPPORT FOR NEW COMMON EQUIPMENTS

1. This procedure is for use by national consumer

logistic planning staff when considering the follow-on logistic support

needed for common weapons systems or major equipments after they enter

service.

2. Its purpose is to enable consumer logistic planning

staffs to comply with the EUROGROUP Principles of Co-operation in Logistics

by ensuring that all options for collaboration between participating nations

on follow-on support arrangements are fully considered during the early

phases of a collaborative project.

3. All EUROGROUP nations have signed the Declaration

of Principles on Co-operation in Logistics and EUROLOG nations have issued

instructions within their own Ministries which require operational

requirement staff and production authorities to advise the appropriate

consumer logistic planning staff as soon as it is decided that new or

replacement equipment will be developed as a collaborative project and to

liaise with them in the development of collaborative follow-on support

arrangements through of the equipment development.

4. It is envisaged that the consumer logistic staff

will need to be involved from the beginning of the Pre-Concept/Staff Target

Development Phase through to the Acquisition/Procurement Phase. This

procedure does not extend to the In Service Phase, since it is assumed that

logistic support planning will by then be largely completed and subject to

normal management action. The checks to be made at each phase are set out

below.

5. Staff Target Development Phase

a. Receive notification from Operational Requirements Staff or production

authorities that the weapon or equipment is likely to be the subject of a

collaborative project.

b. Ascertain

(1) which countries are likely to participate in the project;

(2) whether there is any information as to the likely extent of

collaboration on production eg will the weapon be procured from a single

source or be the subject of co-production arrangements?

c. Consider to the extent possible at this stage the type and probable

extent of logistic support required and whether any special storage or

maintenance facilities are likely to be required.

d. Consider whether there are any existing collaborative support

arrangements in force for the weapon being replaced or for similar weapons in

use by the participating nations and whether these could form the basis for

the planning of collaborative support for the new weapon.

e. Consider to the extent possible at this stage whether NAMSA might be

able to provide support facilities and, if not, whether responsibility for

certain aspects of support eg configuration control, procurement of

materials, maintenance etc could be allocated to one of the participants.

f. If a MOU is to be drafted at this stage endeavour to ensure that it is

worded so as not to close any options for later collaboration on follow-on

support and, that, if possible, it includes some undertaking to require

participants to consider prospects for collaborative support during the Staff

Requirement Development Phase.

g. Advise the Operational Requirements Staff or Production authorities

involved of any views which have been formed about prospects for

collaborative support in the light of the above preliminary analysis.

6. Staff Reguirement Development Phase

a. Receive copy of Draft Staff Target and any MOU which may have been

signed during the Staff Target Development Phase.

b. If not already done, establish liaison with the national member of the

Project Group for the equipment concerned.

c. Consider whether and when it would be appropriate to set up a Joint

Steering Committee (para 5a of EUROLOG Guidelimes) and make recommendations

accordingly to the Project Group.

d. Receive copies of the initial draft of systems specifications and

ensure that the views of consumer logistic authorities on design features

which will affect follow-on support arrangements eg reliability and

maintainability, are taken into account in the drafting of these

specifications.

e. If it is decided to negotiate co-production, or licensing agreements

during this phase endeavour to ensure that no options for the development of

collaborative support are closed; this includes assessing what negotiations

are required over intellectual property rights.

f. Commence planning for standardization of maintenance and supply support

in accordance with para 5c, d and e of the EUROLOG guidelines.

g. Endeavour to ensure that follow-on support arrangements, particularly

procurement storage and distribution of spares, arrangements for maintenance

and repair and configuration control, are included in any MOU for the system

development phase which may be drafted at this stage.

7. System Development Phase

a. Receive copy of the agreed Staff Requirement and any further MOU which

may have been signed during the Staff Requirement Development Phase.

b. If not already set up under 5c above, consider whether a Joint Steering

Committee or Joint Working Group should be set up to examine in detail the

possible areas, extent and types of logistic co-operation (para 5a of EUROLOG

Guidelines).

c. Give support to the setting up by the project management authority of a

joint common configuration management system which would help to maximise the

benefit to be obtained from collaborative support arrangements.

d. Continue the consideration and development of options for collaborative

support on which action was started under the previous phase in accordance

with para 5 of the EUROLOG Guidelines and in particular consider

(1) Allocation of responsibility for procurement of materials.

(2) Estblishing common or compatible maintenance policies,

(3) The possibility of setting up common calibration, maintenance or

repair facilities.

using the facilities of NAMSA or one of the participants.

8. Acquisition/Procurement Phase

a. Finalise planning for logistic follow-on support and draw up an MOU or

other formal document defining the co-ordinated logistic support arrangements

mutually agreed.

b. Complete and implement the logistic plan prior to start of In- Service

Phase.

Officielle noter

(* 1) EUROLOG, a specialist subgroup of Eurogroup, has the following

membership: Belgium, Denmark, Federal Republic of Germany, Greece, Italy,

Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Turkey, United Kingdom.

Lignende dokumenter