Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Whether a dominant firm's retroactive volume discounts can breach EU competition law

Court of JusticeCompetition and state aidJudgment in Case C-23/146 October 2015

The question was which tests apply to a dominant firm's retroactive bulk-mail rebates under Article 82 EC. The Court held that all circumstances must be weighed, a price-cost test is not mandatory, and the effect need only be probable.

Read the full judgment

På dansk · En français · Auf Deutsch


The case

Post Danmark A/S, a Danish postal company controlled by the State, held about 95% of the bulk mail market in Denmark in 2007 and 2008 [1][2]. It also held a statutory monopoly on letters up to 50 grams, which covered about 70% of bulk mail [1]. It granted rebates of 6% to 16% on direct advertising mail, based on purchases over a one-year reference period [1]. The rebates were retroactive: once a customer passed a threshold, the final rate applied to all mail sent in that year [1]. Bring Citymail Danmark A/S, the only serious competitor, offered delivery in the Copenhagen area and later withdrew from the market [1]. The Konkurrencerådet, the Danish competition authority, found that the scheme abused a dominant position [1]. The Sø- og Handelsretten then asked the Court of Justice for guidance [1].

The question

The Court had to decide which criteria apply when judging whether such a rebate scheme is capable of excluding competitors under Article 82 EC [1]. It also had to decide whether an as-efficient-competitor test is required and whether the anticompetitive effect must be serious or appreciable [1].

The outcome

The Court held that the rebate scheme must be assessed on all the circumstances of the case, and that covering most customers may be a useful indication of its effect [1]. It ruled that the as-efficient-competitor test is not a necessary condition for finding abuse [1]. It also held that the anticompetitive effect must be probable, with no need to show that it is serious or appreciable [1]. The dispute itself goes back to the national court, which must decide the outcome [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court started from the principle that a dominant undertaking has a special responsibility not to impair competition [1]. A quantity rebate linked only to the volume of purchases is not, in principle, abusive, whereas a loyalty rebate can be [1]. The rebate here was not tied to a formal obligation to buy all supplies from Post Danmark, so the Court examined all the circumstances [1]. Relevant factors included the criteria and rules for granting the rebate, its retroactive effect, the one-year reference period, and the extent of the dominant position [1]. Because the rebates made it harder for customers to switch suppliers without losing discounts, the Court found that they could produce an anticompetitive exclusionary effect [1]. On the as-efficient-competitor test, the Court said that the Commission's enforcement guidance does not bind national authorities [1]. Where the market structure makes an as-efficient competitor practically impossible, the Court said the test is of no relevance [1]. On the level of effect, the Court said that fixing an appreciability threshold is not justified, because such practices are by nature liable to restrict competition [1]. Finally, the dominant undertaking may justify its conduct by showing efficiency gains that benefit consumers, and it must show that those gains outweigh the negative effects [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment shows that a rebate scheme can be assessed on its overall circumstances, and that a price-cost test is not a legal prerequisite [1]. On this reading, the reasoning is closely tied to the facts: a very high market share, a statutory monopoly covering most of the market, and high barriers to entry [1]. It is therefore hard to read the judgment as a general rule that every rebate scheme is abusive, or that an as-efficient-competitor test is never useful [1]. The Court also left factual questions to the national court, including whether switching suppliers would have cost customers rebates [1]. The judgment does not decide the dispute between Post Danmark and the competition authority, and it does not set a numerical threshold for when a rebate covers the majority of customers [1]. The Court applied the pre-Lisbon wording of Article 82 EC, and the Advocate General noted that the same wording is found in Article 102 TFEU [2]. This is an assessment only, and it is not legal advice. It should not be used to predict how other rebate cases will be decided [1].

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General proposed that Article 82 EC does not require an as-efficient-competitor test for rebate schemes [2]. The Court's answer on the as-efficient-competitor test follows the same line, and the Court also set out that the test is one tool among others [1]. The case turned on the prohibition of abuse of a dominant position in Article 82 EC [1]. Later judgments cite it in different ways. One describes the as-efficient-competitor test as one of several ways to show abuse, not a mandatory one [3]. Another cites it for the view that fixing an appreciability threshold for abuse is not justified [4].

From the sources

the anticompetitive effect of a rebate scheme operated by a dominant undertaking must be probable, there being no need to show that it is of a serious or appreciable nature. [1]
the application of the as-efficient-competitor test does not constitute a necessary condition for a finding to the effect that a rebate scheme is abusive under Article 82 EC. [1]
The fact that the rebate scheme covers the majority of customers on the market may constitute a useful indication as to the extent of that practice and its impact on the market [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-23/14: Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 6 October 2015. — Post Danmark A/S v Konkurrencerådet. the judgment · 6 October 2015
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-23/14: Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 21 May 2015. — Post Danmark A/S v Konkurrencerådet. the Advocate General's opinion · 21 May 2015
  3. Judgment in Case C-377/20: Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 12 May 2022. — Servizio Elettrico Nazionale SpA and Others v Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato and Others. a later judgment that cites this case · 12 May 2022
  4. Judgment in Case C-525/16: Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 19 April 2018. — MEO – Serviços de Comunicações e Multimédia SA v Autoridade da Concorrência. a later judgment that cites this case · 19 April 2018