Data watchdogs can check US data transfers, and the Safe Harbour deal is void
In the Schrems case, the Court asked if a national data authority must follow an EU adequacy decision on the US despite a complaint. It ruled the authority may examine the complaint and declared Decision 2000/520 invalid.
The case
The applicant, an Austrian national, has used the Facebook social network since 2008. Facebook Ireland, a subsidiary of the US company Facebook Inc., asks EU users to sign a contract with it. Some or all of the personal data of EU users is transferred to servers of Facebook Inc. in the United States, where it is processed [1]. In June 2013 the applicant complained to the Irish Data Protection Commissioner and asked him to stop these transfers. He argued that US law and practice did not protect the data against surveillance by public authorities, pointing to revelations about the US National Security Agency [1]. The Commissioner refused to investigate. He relied on Commission Decision 2000/520, which found that the United States ensured an adequate level of protection under the Safe Harbour scheme [1]. The applicant challenged that refusal before the High Court, which referred questions to the Court of Justice [1].
The question
The Court had to decide whether a Commission decision finding that a third country ensures an adequate level of protection stops a national supervisory authority from examining a complaint that the country does not in fact protect the data [1]. It also had to decide whether Decision 2000/520 was valid [1].
The outcome
The Court held that the decision does not prevent a national supervisory authority from examining such a complaint [1]. It then held that Decision 2000/520 is invalid, because the Commission did not state that the United States in fact ensures an adequate level of protection [1]. The applicant's complaint was therefore not barred by the decision [1].
The Court’s reasoning
Article 25(6) of Directive 95/46 lets the Commission find that a third country ensures an adequate level of protection [1]. Until the Court declares such a decision invalid, Member States and their authorities cannot adopt measures contrary to it [1]. However, the decision cannot prevent persons from lodging a claim with a national supervisory authority about the protection of their data [1]. Under Article 8(3) of the Charter and Article 28 of the directive, supervisory authorities must be able to examine such claims with complete independence [1]. A national authority cannot itself declare a Commission decision invalid. If it finds the objections well founded, it must be able to bring the matter before a national court, which may refer the question of validity to the Court [1]. On validity, the Court said that an adequate level of protection means a level essentially equivalent to that in the EU [1]. Because many people's rights are at stake, the Commission's discretion is reduced and review must be strict [1]. Decision 2000/520 applied only to self-certified US organisations, let national security and public interest requirements override the principles, and did not refer to effective legal protection against State interference [1]. The Commission's own communications had found that US authorities could access the data beyond what was strictly necessary [1]. Article 3 of the decision exceeded the Commission's power, and the Court declared the whole decision invalid [1].
What the judgment means
On this reading, the main principle of the judgment is that an adequacy decision under Article 25(6) does not remove a national supervisory authority's power to examine a complaint about a transfer to a third country [1]. The Court also held that such a decision must rest on a finding that the third country in fact ensures essentially equivalent protection, and that the Commission must check this periodically [1]. On this reading, the judgment's reach is clearest for the Safe Harbour decision, which it declared invalid [1]. It does not itself set out what other transfer arrangements must contain [1]. It also does not decide whether particular US surveillance programmes are lawful, and it does not say how a national authority must decide a case after examining a complaint [1]. This assessment is ours and is not legal advice. It should not be used to predict the outcome of other cases [1].
How the sources fit together
The Advocate General proposed that the powers of national supervisory authorities must remain intact even where the Commission has adopted a decision under Article 25(6) [2]. The Court reached the same result and relied on Article 28 of the directive and Article 8(3) of the Charter [1]. The case turned on Articles 25(6) and 28 of Directive 95/46, read in the light of Articles 7, 8 and 47 of the Charter [1]. Later judgments cite it for the rule that a supervisory authority must handle a complaint with all due diligence [3], and for the point that a supervisory authority must examine, with complete independence, whether processing complies with the directive even where another Member State's supervisory authority has taken a decision [4]. A later Commission implementing decision refers to the judgment's finding that Article 3 of Decision 2000/520 was invalid [5].
From the sources
a level of protection of fundamental rights and freedoms that is essentially equivalent to that guaranteed within the European Union [1]
cannot prevent persons whose personal data has been or could be transferred to a third country from lodging with the national supervisory authorities a claim [1]
Decision 2000/520 is invalid. [1]
Sources
- Judgment in Case C-362/14: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 6 October 2015. — Maximillian Schrems v Data Protection Commissioner. the judgment · 6 October 2015
- Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-362/14: Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 23 September 2015. — Maximillian Schrems v Data Protection Commissioner. the Advocate General's opinion · 23 September 2015
- Judgment in Case C-311/18: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 16 July 2020. — Data Protection Commissioner v Facebook Ireland Limited and Maximillian Schrems. a later judgment that cites this case · 16 July 2020
- Judgment in Case C-210/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 5 June 2018. — Unabhängiges Landeszentrum für Datenschutz Schleswig-Holstein v Wirtschaftsakademie Schleswig-Holstein GmbH. a later judgment that cites this case · 5 June 2018
- COMMISSION IMPLEMENTING DECISION (EU) 2016/2295 of 16 December 2016 amending Decisions 2000/518/EC, 2002/2/EC, 2003/490/EC, 2003/821/EC, 2004/411/EC, 2008/393/EC, 2010/146/EU, 2010/625/EU, 2011/61/EU and Implementing Decisions 2012/484/EU, 2013/65/EU on the adequate protection of personal data by certain countries, pursuant to Article 25(6) of Directive 95/46/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council (notified under document C(2016) 8353) (Text with EEA relevance) another EU document with similar content · 16 December 2016