Skip to content

Analyses of judgments

Can EU citizenship give a non-EU parent a right to stay where the children never moved?

Court of JusticeMigration and free movementJudgment in Case C-34/098 March 2011

In the Ruiz Zambrano case, the Court asked whether a non-EU parent of EU-citizen children may stay and work where the children never moved. It said yes, if refusal would deprive the children of the substance of their EU citizenship.

Read the full judgment


The case

The worker is a third-country national who lived in Belgium with his wife, who is also a non-EU national. Their asylum and residence requests were refused [1]. The worker took a full-time job without a work permit [1]. Two of the couple's children were born in Belgium and hold Belgian nationality, which makes them EU citizens [1]. The worker later claimed unemployment benefit, but the benefit was refused because his work had not complied with the rules on foreign workers [1]. The children have never left Belgium. The worker argued that, as the parent of EU-citizen children, he had a right to reside and needed no work permit [1]. The Belgian labour court referred questions to the Court of Justice on how EU citizenship law applies [1].

The question

The Court had to decide whether Article 20 TFEU gives a non-EU parent of dependent minor EU citizens a right of residence, and an exemption from a work permit, in the Member State where the children live and hold nationality, even though the children have never moved to another Member State [1]. The Court also had to consider whether the free-movement directive applies to such a situation [1].

The outcome

The Court held that Article 20 TFEU precludes a Member State from refusing a third-country national with dependent EU-citizen minor children a right of residence and a work permit, where those refusals deprive the children of the genuine enjoyment of the substance of their EU citizenship [1]. The Court answered in favour of the worker's line of argument in principle, but left the outcome of the claim to the national court, which also decides costs [1].

The Court’s reasoning

The Court started from the point that citizenship of the Union is intended to be the fundamental status of nationals of the Member States [1]. It accepted that the children, as Belgian nationals, hold EU citizenship under Article 20 TFEU, the Treaty article on EU citizenship [1]. The Court then held that Article 20 precludes national measures that deprive EU citizens of the genuine enjoyment of the substance of the rights linked to that status [1]. A refusal of residence to a parent with dependent children would have that effect. The Court reasoned that the children would then have to leave the territory of the Union to accompany their parents [1]. A refusal of a work permit would also risk leaving the parent without sufficient resources to support the family. That loss of support would likewise force the children to leave the Union [1]. The Court did not rely on the free-movement directive. It found that the directive did not apply, because the children had never moved to or resided in a Member State other than their own [1]. The Court therefore based its answer directly on Article 20 TFEU. It did not give a separate answer on the Charter of Fundamental Rights, which the referring court had also raised [1].

What the judgment means

On this reading, the judgment establishes that EU citizenship under Article 20 TFEU can, in some cases, give a right to reside in the Member State of the children's nationality, even where no cross-border movement has taken place [1]. The test is whether the refusal would deprive the children of the genuine enjoyment of the substance of their EU citizenship [1]. The judgment concerns young children who depend on a parent, and it does not state how far the principle reaches for older children or other relatives [1]. It also does not decide whether a national court must grant a particular permit or benefit, leaving that to the referring court [1]. The Advocate General described the possible effects on the family as potentially a significant breach of family life, but the Court's answer rests on Article 20 alone [2][1]. This is an assessment only, and it is not legal advice. We cannot predict how the principle will apply in other cases.

How the sources fit together

The Advocate General's opinion framed the questions and examined whether the children's situation had a sufficient link with EU law [2]. The opinion excerpt available here does not show its final answer, so we cannot say whether the Court followed it in every respect [2]. The Court's reasoning rests on Article 20 TFEU and does not discuss the Charter [1]. Later judgments cite this case. In one, the referring court noted that the Zhu and Chen and Ruiz Zambrano situations involved removal of minor Union citizens from EU territory [3]. In another, the referring court considered that administrative bodies interpret this judgment restrictively [4]. In a third, the referring court stated that its principles apply only in exceptional circumstances [5].

From the sources

Citizenship of the Union is intended to be the fundamental status of nationals of the Member States [1]
Article 20 TFEU precludes national measures which have the effect of depriving citizens of the Union of the genuine enjoyment of the substance of the rights conferred by virtue of their status as citizens of the Union [1]
those citizens of the Union would, in fact, be unable to exercise the substance of the rights conferred on them by virtue of their status as citizens of the Union [1]

Sources

  1. Judgment in Case C-34/09: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 March 2011. — Gerardo Ruiz Zambrano v Office national de l’emploi (ONEm). the judgment · 8 March 2011
  2. Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-34/09: Opinion of Advocate General Sharpston delivered on 30 September 2010. — Gerardo Ruiz Zambrano v Office national de l’emploi (ONEm). the Advocate General's opinion · 30 September 2010
  3. Judgment in Case C-165/14: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 13 September 2016. — Alfredo Rendón Marín v Administración del Estado. a later judgment that cites this case · 13 September 2016
  4. Judgment in Case C-133/15: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 10 May 2017. — H.C. Chavez-Vilchez and Others v Raad van bestuur van de Sociale verzekeringsbank and Others. a later judgment that cites this case · 10 May 2017
  5. Judgment in Case C-82/16: Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 May 2018. — K.A. and Others v Belgische Staat. a later judgment that cites this case · 8 May 2018